HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You own the water company now," she said. "You can fix this. You can let the water keep flowing. You are the one doing this to us."

I let her finish. I let her say it all, the part about the community and the part about the families and the part about the children who needed water for their pools and their lawns, and I listened, and I thought about the corn in the north field and the ponds and the soil that had been dry for months, and I thought about the nearly four hundred percent, and I thought about the millions of dollars, and I thought about the six years.

Then I said the only thing there was to say, the thing Melissa had told me to say if Karen called, the thing that was true whether Karen liked it or not.

"Karen," I said, "I own the water company, but I do not own the rules. The regulator is the one controlling the rules now. The regulator is the one who said the pipe is not permitted. The regulator is the one who said the easement expired. I cannot give you water through a pipe you have no right to use, because the law will not let me, and I will not break the law to fix a problem you spent six years creating."

She argued. Of course she argued. She said the regulator did not understand the community. She said the county did not understand the community. She said I did not understand the community, which was strange, because I had lived next to that community for longer than she had been its president, and I understood it very well. I understood that it was made up of good people who had trusted her, and who were now going to pay for that trust.

She said there had to be a way. She said there was always a way. She said I was being stubborn and vindictive and small, and I listened to all of it, and I did not raise my voice, because I had learned, by then, that raising your voice does not make a fact any truer, and it does not make a lie any less false.

When she finally stopped, I said, "You have thirty days, Karen. Use them."

Over the next month, the HOA did everything it could do, and I watched it happen, not with satisfaction, but with the grim attention of a man watching a neighbor try to fix a roof in a storm. They sought an emergency extension. They appealed the decision. They hired engineers, good engineers, expensive engineers, who came out in white trucks and walked the land with clipboards and measuring tapes and shook their heads. They negotiated with the county, in meeting after meeting, in rooms with long tables and pitchers of water that nobody drank, because the water in the pitchers had come from somewhere, and everyone in the room knew where it had come from.

But they could not solve it. That was the plain truth of it, and it was a truth that no amount of money and no amount of lawyers and no amount of meetings could change. They could not solve it because the solution was not a piece of paper. The solution was a new lawful pipe, a pipe that did not cross my land on an expired easement, a pipe that did not take water through an agricultural diversion it had no right to use, a pipe that would have to be designed and permitted and built from scratch, and a pipe like that costs millions of dollars. Millions. The same word that had come up in Melissa's office, when we were talking about the maintenance fees, came up again now, when we were talking about the cost of fixing what Karen had broken.

I went to the final board meeting. I did not go to gloat. I went because Melissa told me I should be there, and because I wanted to hear, with my own ears, what the board would say when it could no longer hide behind Karen's voice. The room was full. It was fuller than any board meeting I had ever heard about, with residents standing along the walls and sitting on the floor, and the air in the room was hot and close, and the questions came fast, one after another, from people who had paid their fees and watered their lawns and trusted their president, and who were now learning, all at once, what that trust had cost them.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

45 Part