The audit came back, and when it came back, it was worse than I had expected, and I had expected it to be bad. The engineers laid it out for me in a meeting in Melissa's office, with diagrams and charts and photographs, and they spoke in the careful language of people who know that what they are saying will end up in a courtroom. Briar Ridge had grown far beyond its original design capacity. The system that served it had been built for a small community, a handful of homes, and over the years the HOA had grown, and grown, and grown, and no one had ever upgraded the infrastructure to match. They were using water for the fountain, and for the pool, and for the irrigation, and for the ornamental pond, and they were using it through infrastructure that had been meant only temporarily for construction, pipes and lines that were never intended to carry that much water for that long, to that many homes, for that many purposes.
And the pipe, the pipe that crossed my land, that pipe crossed many private properties, and it did so without a current easement on any of them, or at least without a current easement that anyone could produce. It was a line drawn across the valley years ago, and the valley had changed around it, and the paperwork had not kept up, and the result was a system that existed in practice but not in law, a system that worked only because no one had ever stopped to ask whether it was allowed to work.
I read that report twice, and then I read it a third time, and then I called Melissa, and I told her what I wanted to do, and she listened, and she asked me if I was sure, and I told her I was sure, and she drafted the notice, and we sent it, by certified mail, to the Briar Ridge board. The notice was formal, and it was specific, and it said, in plain language, that the HOA had thirty days to establish lawful access to the water, or to disconnect from the disputed pipe. Thirty days. Not a threat, not a punishment, but a deadline, the kind of deadline the law understands, the kind of deadline that gives a man time to do the right thing before the consequences arrive.
The board did not do the right thing. The board sued. They filed a lawsuit against me, and against the cooperative, and against the holding company, and they accused me of retaliation, and they said that I had bought the company for the sole purpose of punishing them, and they asked the court to stop me, and to force me to keep the water flowing, and to declare that they had a right to it, forever, without question. I remember the day the papers arrived, and I remember sitting at my kitchen table with Melissa on the phone, reading the complaint, and feeling a strange calm settle over me, because I had expected this, and because I had prepared for this, and because, for the first time in this whole fight, I was not the one who was afraid.
Melissa said something to me that day that I have never forgotten. "This lawsuit helps us, Daniel," she said. "I know it does not feel that way, but it does. Because now the court will determine ownership, and the court will determine access, and the court will look at the paperwork, and the paperwork is on our side. They have brought this into a courtroom, and a courtroom is the one place where shouting does not work, and where the only thing that matters is what you can prove."
And so we went to court, and the litigation began, and it was slow, the way litigation is always slow, with filings and responses and hearings that were scheduled and rescheduled, and with lawyers talking in hallways and judges asking questions that seemed simple and were not. Briar Ridge produced documents, and we produced documents, and the court looked at them all, and for a long time it seemed as if nothing was happening, as if the whole thing were stuck in the mud, and I would come home from those hearings tired and frustrated, and I would walk out into my fields, and I would remind myself why I was doing this, and I would think about my grandfather's ditch, and about the water that had belonged to this land for generations, and I would keep going.