Where did the money go? Why was the easement never renewed? Why did we use four times our allowance during a drought? Why did the water company pay for our repairs? Why did you walk away from the reporter? The questions kept coming, and Karen sat at the front table, and for the first time since I had known her, she did not have an answer that sounded reasonable. She had excuses, and she had deflections, and she had the same phrase about an attack on the community, but the room was no longer listening to that phrase the way it once had.
And then the board's lawyer stood up. He was a quiet man, older, with gray hair and a suit that looked like it had been bought a long time ago and taken good care of, and he did not raise his voice, and he did not try to make it sound better than it was. He just stated the fact, plainly, the way a lawyer states a fact when there is no longer any way to dress it up.
They had used the pipe for about eighteen years.
Eighteen years. I sat in the back of that room and I did the arithmetic in my head, the way a farmer does arithmetic, slowly and carefully, because a wrong number can cost you a season. Eighteen years of water through a pipe that had been lawful for twelve of them and unlawful for six. Eighteen years of lawns and fountains and waterfalls. Eighteen years of fees and repairs and renewals that had happened and then stopped happening. Eighteen years, and it had all come down to thirty days, and thirty days was not enough, and everyone in that room knew it, including Karen, especially Karen.
The meeting ended without a solution. There was no solution to vote on. There was only the decision, and the thirty days, and the clock, ticking.
On day thirty-one, I received the final management authorization. It came in an envelope, not an email, a thick envelope with the regulator's seal on it, and Melissa brought it to the farm herself, because she wanted to be the one to hand it to me, and she wanted to see my face when I read it. I read it standing in the kitchen, with Earl Thompson standing beside me, because Earl had come by that morning to check the pump, and he had stayed when he saw the envelope, and he had stayed because he knew what was in it, and he knew what it meant.
The authorization was simple. It said I was authorized, as the owner of the water company and as the manager of the diversion, to close the disputed pipe. It said the thirty days had passed. It said no lawful connection had been established. It said the emergency restrictions remained in effect. It said the closure was to be carried out in a way that did not cut off drinking water to residents and did not drain private pools. Only the unlawful pipe was to be stopped.
I folded the paper and put it in my shirt pocket, and Earl and I drove out to the control station in his truck, because my truck had a flat tire that morning, and Earl said his truck was already warm, and I did not argue. The control station is a small concrete building at the edge of my land, where the main line splits, one way toward the farm and one way toward Briar Ridge, and it smells of oil and damp concrete and rust, the way places that hold water always smell. Earl had been in that building a hundred times. I had been in it a hundred times. We knew every valve in it by sight, and we knew which one was the disputed one, because it was the one with the newer paint on it, the one the water company had replaced three winters back, at the company's expense, when the HOA should have paid for it.
We stood in front of the main shutoff valve, and for a moment neither of us said anything. Earl looked at me, and I looked at the valve, and the valve was just a wheel of iron, cold to the touch, with a handle that had been turned a thousand times by a thousand hands, and it did not know anything about eighteen years or thirty days or millions of dollars. It only knew open and closed.
I put my hand on it. I felt the cold of the iron through my palm, and I felt the weight of it, and I thought about all the times I had stood in that same spot and wished I could turn that wheel, and all the times I had told myself not to, because the law had not yet said I could, and because a farmer does not take the law into his own hands, even when the law is slow and the water is gone and the corn is dying.