We walked down to the creek together, and I showed him the intake and the old diversion and the place where the unlawful connection had been made, and he listened without interrupting, and he asked the kind of questions a practical man asks, the kind that have numbers in them. How much water did the farm use in a dry year. How much did it use in a wet year. How much could it spare without harming the crops or the creek. What would it cost to build a proper system, with a proper pipe and a proper meter and a proper agreement. He did not haggle. He did not threaten. He did not pretend that Briar Ridge had any right to what it had been taking. He simply wanted to know what a fair arrangement would look like, and whether I would be willing to make one.
What he proposed was simple, and the simplicity of it was what made it work. He proposed that Briar Ridge negotiate with me and buy water from my company at market price, if the regulator approved, with no special terms. No discount because they were a neighborhood. No premium because they had once taken it for free. No quiet handshake and no secret understanding. Market price, a written agreement, a meter that both sides could read, and the approval of the regulator, so that no one could come back later and say that the deal had been made in the dark. He said it the way a man says something he has already thought through, and I could tell that he had thought it through, because there was nothing in his voice that sounded like he was trying to win a point. He sounded like a man trying to solve a problem.
I agreed to negotiate, and I meant it, because a fair price for water is not a punishment, and it is not a reward either. It is simply what water is worth when you have to work to bring it to the surface and keep it clean and keep it flowing. I had never wanted to cut Briar Ridge off. I had wanted them to ask, and to pay, and to tell the truth about where their water came from, and Robert Ellis was the first person from that neighborhood who had come to my farm and done all three of those things in the same visit.
The new system took eighteen months to complete, and I will not pretend those eighteen months were easy, because building something properly always takes longer than taking something improperly, and there were days when I wondered whether the old way, for all its dishonesty, had at least been faster. It had been faster. It had also been wrong, and I had learned by then that fast and wrong is not a bargain, it is a debt, and the debt always comes due. So we did it the slow way, the right way, the way that would still be standing when the people who built it were gone.
Briar Ridge paid for its own pipe. I want to be clear about that, because it mattered, and it mattered for reasons that went beyond money. The neighborhood that had once taken my water through a connection no one had told me about now paid, out of its own funds, for a pipe that belonged to it, that carried water it had bought, through a route that everyone could see. The county approved the design, and the approval was not a formality, it was a real review by real engineers who looked at the plans and asked questions and made changes, and when they signed off on it I felt something settle in me that had been unsettled for a long time. The old unlawful connection was permanently removed, not capped and not hidden and not left in place for a rainy day, but removed, the ground restored, the pipe taken out, so that no one could ever quietly open a valve in the night and pretend nothing had happened.
And the HOA set up a drought-compliance committee. I know how that sounds, like one more committee in a neighborhood that already had too many of them, but this one was different, because it had a job that was written down and a job that could be checked. No decorative fountains during restrictions. No over-watering lawns. No more secret water contracts or infrastructure. The rules were posted where everyone could read them, and the committee was made up of residents who had volunteered, not of people who had been appointed by a president who wanted them to look the other way. I did not attend their meetings. I did not need to. I knew that the system would work or it would not, and that no committee could make it work if the people behind it did not want it to work, and that the best sign I had seen in a long time was that the people of Briar Ridge had chosen, this time, to do it in the open.