During those months, I did something else, something I had been thinking about since the day I first sat in Daniel Brooks's office and listened to him talk about the pipe that nobody had checked. I ordered an infrastructure audit. I hired engineers, independent engineers with no connection to the cooperative and no connection to Briar Ridge, and I told them to look at everything. I told them to map every pipe, to trace every connection, to measure every flow, to find every place where water was going that should not have been going there, and to write it all down, because I was tired of operating in the dark. I was tired of guessing. I wanted to know, in black and white, what this company actually was.
The engineers worked for weeks. They walked the land, and they opened valve boxes, and they took readings, and they followed lines across fields and under roads, and they asked questions of people who had worked on the system for years, and slowly, piece by piece, a picture began to emerge, and it was not a pretty picture. I remember the day they brought me their first report, and I remember sitting at my kitchen table with the pages spread out in front of me, and I remember the feeling in my stomach as I read, because what they were showing me was a system that had grown the way a weed grows, without a plan, without permission, without anyone stopping to ask whether it should grow at all.
And while the audit was underway, I did something that Melissa told me was necessary, even though I knew it would make me unpopular. I froze the undocumented connections. There were connections on the system, connections that had no paperwork, no agreement, no record of any kind, and I ordered them frozen, which meant that no new undocumented connection would be made, and that the existing undocumented connections would be reviewed, one by one, to determine whether they had any lawful basis at all. I announced, in writing, to every customer of the cooperative, that service would continue under lawful agreements. I said it plainly, in language that left no room for misunderstanding: if you have a lawful agreement, you will be served. If you do not, we will sort it out, lawfully, and in the open. I did not threaten anyone. I did not name Karen Whitmore. I did not have to. The letter went out, and the phone started ringing, and one of the first calls was from her.
"You bought the company because of me," she said, and her voice was sharp, the way it had been sharp in the clubhouse that day, and I could hear the anger in it, and underneath the anger I could hear something else, something I had not heard from her before, and that something was fear. "You bought it because of me, and you are going to cut the water to the whole neighborhood, and everyone will know it was you, and everyone will know why."
I stood in my kitchen with the phone in my hand, and I looked out the window at my fields, and I thought about the week my well had run dry, and I thought about my crops standing in the sun, and I thought about the fountain in Briar Ridge dancing while my land went thirsty, and I answered her the way I had decided I would answer her, calmly and plainly, because I had learned by then that calmness was the one thing she could not stand.
"The company will follow the law," I said. "That is what the company will do. If the HOA has a valid agreement, it will still be served. If it does not, then we will deal with that lawfully, the same as we will deal with everyone else. I am not cutting water to anyone who has a right to it, Karen. I am only asking that the rights be real."
She did not like that answer. I could hear it in the silence on the other end of the line, and then she said something about lawyers, and something about the board, and something about how this was not over, and then she hung up, and I stood there for a long time with the phone still in my hand, listening to the dial tone, and thinking about how strange it was that a woman who had taken my water without a second thought was now frightened by the idea that the law might finally be applied to her.