HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then, in the middle of the litigation, Briar Ridge produced a contract. They produced it with a great deal of ceremony, as if it were the answer to everything, as if it were the document that would end the case in their favor. It was an old contract, signed nineteen years ago, and it was eight pages long, and it was, according to their lawyer, the proof that they had a right to the water, a right that had been granted long ago and had never been taken away. I remember Melissa leaning over to me in the courtroom when their lawyer held it up, and I remember her whispering, "Count the pages," and I remember thinking that was a strange thing to say, until I counted them, and I realized that there were only seven pages.

Seven pages. The contract was supposed to be eight pages long, and they had submitted seven. And the missing page, the page that was not there, was page seven. Page seven, the page that, according to the table of contents, contained the termination clause. The clause that said when the agreement ended, and under what conditions, and what happened when those conditions were met. The most important page in the entire contract, and it was missing, and their lawyer, when the judge asked about it, said that it must have been misfiled, or lost, or that it was not relevant, and the judge looked at him the way judges look at lawyers who are trying to explain away something that cannot be explained away, and the judge ordered the original produced.

The original. Not a copy, not a summary, not a version with a page missing, but the original contract, the one that had been signed nineteen years ago, with all eight pages, including page seven. And for two weeks, nothing happened. Two weeks of waiting, two weeks of silence, two weeks of wondering whether the page would ever appear, or whether it had been destroyed, or whether it had never existed at all. I went about my work during those two weeks, and I tried not to think about it, and I thought about it constantly, because I knew, the way you know something in your gut before you know it in your head, that page seven was the whole case.

And then, after two weeks, the page appeared. It was produced, finally, reluctantly, and it was placed before the court, and Melissa read it, and then she read it again, and then she handed it to me, and I read it, and I understood, in that moment, why it had been missing for so long. The agreement, the contract that Briar Ridge had held up as proof of their eternal right to the water, that agreement had automatically expired when city water arrived. That was what page seven said, in plain language that left no room for argument. The agreement ended when city water came to the area, and city water had arrived fourteen years ago. Fourteen years. For fourteen years, Briar Ridge had been taking water under an agreement that no longer existed, and no one had noticed, or no one had wanted to notice, because the water kept flowing and the bills kept getting paid, and the pipe should have been disconnected fourteen years ago, but earlier HOA presidents had kept the service going, year after year, president after president, as if a contract that had expired were still alive simply because no one had bothered to read page seven.

The two weeks of negotiation with Daniel Brooks taught me more about the man than any single conversation could have. He was not a man who hurried, and he was not a man who bluffed, and he was not a man who pretended to be something he was not. He came to every meeting with a notebook, a real paper notebook with a spiral binding, and he wrote things down in pencil, and when he disagreed with something I said, he did not argue, he simply turned the pencil over in his hand and said, "Tell me why," and then he listened. I respected that. I respected a man who listened before he answered, because I had spent too much time in rooms with people who answered before they listened, and I knew the difference.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

45 Part