"How long has it been like this?" he asked.
"Since yesterday morning it was low," I said. "This morning it was nothing. Just mud."
He nodded, as if that matched something he already expected, and he went to the valve. It was a big cast-iron gate valve on the main line, painted green years ago and now chipped and rusted at the edges, and he worked the wheel slowly, feeling the resistance, listening to the way it turned. He opened it all the way, then closed it partway, then opened it again, his ear close to the pipe, his hand flat against the metal as if he could feel the water through it. There was nothing to feel. The pipe was quiet. A healthy line hums, just a little, a low vibration you can feel in your palm when the water is moving through it. This one was dead.
He moved to the pressure gauge next, a round brass dial mounted on a short standpipe beside the valve, and he tapped the glass with one knuckle, the way you tap a gauge that might be stuck. The needle sat at zero and did not move. He bent down and looked at it from the side, checking that the glass was not fogged, that the needle had not simply fallen off its pin, and then he straightened up and shook his head.
"Gauge is fine," he said. "There's just nothing to measure."
He walked fifty yards upstream after that, following the bank where the creek cut through the willows, stepping carefully over roots and through the tall grass, stopping every few feet to look at the water, or what was left of it. I followed him, because I could not stand still, and because I wanted to see what he was seeing. The creek was a thin ribbon now, no wider than a man's hand in places, running clear over the stones but too shallow to cover them, with muddy banks exposed on both sides where the water had been a foot deep only days before. Upstream, where the channel narrowed between two low banks, there were stranded minnows in a shallow pool, flicking their tails in water that would not last the day. Earl stopped and looked at them for a moment, and something in his face tightened, the way a man's face tightens when he sees an animal suffering for no good reason.
He kept walking, and I kept following, and when we had gone fifty yards he stopped and turned around and looked back down the creek toward my farm, toward the intake and the dry fields beyond it. He stood there for a while, his hands on his hips, his hat pushed back on his head, and he did not speak. I waited. I have learned, over years of working with men like Earl, that silence is not the same as having nothing to say. Sometimes a man is quiet because he is putting the pieces together, and the worst thing you can do is rush him.
After ten minutes he came back down the bank toward me, walking slowly, his boots leaving prints in the soft mud, and he stopped in front of the intake and looked at it one more time.
"Daniel," he said, and his voice was flat and certain, the way it gets when he has made up his mind about something and there is no use arguing with him, "your water is not lost. It has been diverted downstream."
I stared at him. "Diverted? Earl, there is nothing downstream of my intake except my own fields. The creek runs through my land and then it runs on to the lower valley. Nobody diverts it."
"Somebody did," he said. "Water does not just disappear like this. Not in one night, not with the ground still wet up here and the creek still running thin but steady above your intake. If the creek had dried up at the source, there would be nothing up there either. But there is water up there. It is just not getting to you. That means it is being taken out of the creek between here and where it should reach your intake, or it is being pulled off somewhere you cannot see from the bank."
He pointed upstream with one hand and then swept it down toward the road that ran along the edge of my property, the county road that separated Mercer Farm from the land beyond it, where the houses of Briar Ridge stood on their manicured lots behind their white fences.