HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

Chapter 42

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Karen Whitmore resigned before the new pipeline was completed. I heard about it the way you hear about most things in a small place, not from a letter or an announcement, but from a neighbor who stopped me at the feed store and said it quietly, as if he were telling me about a death in the family. She had not waited for the work to be finished. She had not stayed to see the water flowing through a pipe that had been paid for and approved and measured. She had resigned, and the resignation had been accepted, and that was that, except that it was not that, because Karen Whitmore was not the kind of woman to leave quietly and never be heard from again.

She attended a final crowded HOA meeting. I was not there, and I did not need to be there to know what the room must have felt like, because I had sat in that room myself and I knew the way the air went still when something real was about to be said. The room was full, people standing along the walls, people who had come because they had heard that Karen was going to speak, and because they wanted to hear what she would say now that the fight was over and the records were public and the pipeline was being built without her. She stood up, and she said she believed she was protecting Briar Ridge. She said it plainly, without raising her voice, and I believe she meant it, because people who do the wrong thing for the wrong reasons are easier to understand than people who do the wrong thing while believing they are doing the right thing, and Karen had always believed she was doing the right thing. She admitted she had made decisions she thought were necessary, decisions that had seemed necessary at the time, decisions that had looked different from inside the room where they were made than they looked from outside it, and I could imagine the silence in that room as she said it, the silence of people who were hearing a woman they had once trusted try to explain herself to them.

Then she turned to me, or rather she turned to the idea of me, because I was not in the room, and she said, in front of all those people, that I had won. She said it the way people say it when they think that winning is the point, when they think that a fight ends with one person standing and the other person on the ground, and I wish I had been there to answer her in person, because the answer I would have given her was the answer I gave later, when the words were carried back to me. I did not win in that sense. I did not win the way a man wins a race or a game. She lost because the records did not support what she claimed. That is a different thing entirely. It is not about me being stronger or cleverer or more determined. It is about the truth being written down in places where it could be found, in permits and in meters and in minutes and in contracts, and about a woman who had built her case on the assumption that no one would ever go and look.

She admitted it, one by one, in that room, and I want to record it here because it matters that she said it out loud, in front of the people she had led. She said she should have asked. She should have asked where the water came from, and who it belonged to, and what it would cost to buy it honestly, before she ever took it. She said she should have negotiated. She should have come to my farm and sat at my table and talked about a price, instead of building a system in secret and hoping no one would notice. She said she should have told the residents. She should have told them the truth about the water, and about the farm, and about the risks they were taking, instead of telling them a story about a farmer who was trying to restrict them. She said it slowly, each admission standing on its own, and then she said the words that no one in that room had expected to hear from her, the words that, once said, could not be taken back.

"I was wrong."

News in the same category

HOA Karen Took My Farm's Water — So I Bought the Pipeline Company She Depended On

45 Part