It did not. Or most of it did not. The water company paid most of the repair costs. I knew that because I had bought the water company, and when I bought it, I bought its books, and its books showed, year after year, repair after repair, the company paying for work the HOA was contractually responsible for. The company had paid for the new valve at the north junction. It had paid for the resealing at the creek crossing. It had paid for the pump repair after the freeze three winters back. It had paid, and paid, and paid, while the HOA collected the fees and kept them.
"Where did it go?" I asked Melissa.
She did not answer right away. She turned over another page in the file, and then another, and the pages were bank statements and ledgers and spreadsheets, and the numbers on them did not add up. They did not add up in the way that numbers do not add up when someone has been moving them around and hoping nobody will check the arithmetic. The maintenance fees came in, month after month, from hundreds of households, and the repair costs went out, mostly from the water company, and the difference between what came in and what went out was not small. It was not a rounding error. It was not a few hundred dollars that had been misfiled. The story in the books, the story Melissa pieced together from the statements and the invoices and the county records, was that millions of dollars were unaccounted for.
Millions. I said the word out loud in her office, and it sounded wrong in my mouth, too big for the room, too big for a homeowners association in a subdivision with a fountain and an ornamental waterfall. I thought about what a million dollars meant on a farm. It meant a new tractor and a new barn and a new well and still money left over. It meant ten years of seed and fertilizer. It meant the difference between a farm that survived a drought and a farm that did not. And here was an HOA that had collected millions in fees for work it had not done, while the water company paid for the repairs and the farmers went without water.
Melissa closed the file and looked at me across the desk. She was not a woman who raised her voice. She did not need to. She had a way of saying a thing quietly that made it land harder than if she had shouted it.
"Daniel," she said, "this is no longer just a water dispute."
I knew what she meant. A water dispute is about a pipe and a date and a rule. A water dispute can be settled with a letter and a meeting and a new agreement. This was no longer that. This was about money that had been collected and not spent, about a contract that had been ignored, about an easement that had been allowed to expire, and about a community that had been told one thing while another thing was happening behind its back. This was about a president who had used the water, used the pipe, used the fees, and used the silence of the people who trusted her, and had done it for years.
I went home that night and walked my fields in the dark. The soil was still dry. The ponds were still low. The irrigation channels were still empty. And I thought about the millions of dollars, and I thought about the water that had flowed uphill to Briar Ridge while my crops died, and I thought about the fact that Karen had not just taken my water. She had taken the residents' money, too, and she had taken it while smiling at them at neighborhood meetings and telling them she was protecting their community.
The state regulator began an investigation, and I will be honest with you, I did not know what that meant at first. I had dealt with regulators before, in the ordinary way a farmer deals with regulators, which is to say I filled out forms, I reported my usage, I kept my allotment, and I did what I was told. I had never been on the other side of an investigation, the side where a government office starts asking questions and pulling records and sending letters with official seals on them, and I did not know whether to be relieved or afraid. Melissa told me to be neither. She told me to be patient, and to keep farming, and to let the paper do the work.