The first board was the simplest one, and in some ways it was the one that mattered most, because it took away the only defense Karen had left, which was that she had not known. She had known. Or if she had not known, she had chosen not to know, and in the law, Melissa told me, that is often the same thing.
Karen had not written the original agreement. She had inherited it. That was true, and I never pretended otherwise. The agreement had been signed long before she became president of the Briar Ridge Homeowners Association, by men whose names were now only signatures on yellowing paper in a county file. The earlier presidents had maintained it. That was the word Melissa used, maintained, and she said it the way a farmer says maintained about a fence line, meaning somebody had walked it, checked it, kept it in repair, and understood what it was for. For years, the agreement had been a living thing. The HOA had paid its share. The water company had paid its share. The pipe had been inspected. The easement had been renewed when it needed renewing, or at least the men in charge had believed it had been renewed, and the paper had been filed where paper was supposed to be filed.
Karen inherited that agreement six years after those earlier presidents had maintained it. Six years. I kept coming back to that number because it was long enough to learn a job and long enough to forget a job, and Karen had done neither. She had held the presidency for eight years by the time the water stopped reaching my fields, which meant she had been in charge for two years before the easement expired and six years after it should have mattered to her. She had sat in the chair long enough to read every file in the HOA office, and the office was not large. I had seen it once, years earlier, when I went in to pay a fee for a fence permit on the edge of my land, and it was a single room with a filing cabinet, a desk, and a window that looked out over the ornamental pond they were so proud of. There was not so much paper in that room that a person could lose an easement in it by accident.
Melissa laid it out for me on her office table, the way she laid everything out, in a neat row, left to right, oldest to newest. Here was the original agreement, with the signatures. Here was the renewal, and here was the second renewal, and here was the date the easement had expired, circled in red. Here was the letter the county had sent, years earlier, reminding the HOA that the easement would need to be renewed. Here was the letter the water company had sent, reminding them of the same thing. And here, at the end of the row, was nothing. No renewal. No application. No letter asking for more time. Just a gap, six years wide, where the paper should have been.
"She inherited a working agreement," Melissa said. "She did not inherit a mystery. She inherited a file with a date in it."
"She looked," Melissa said. "Or she had someone look for her. Either way, Daniel, she knew."
The second board was the maintenance clause, and it was worse than the first, because it was not about forgetting. It was about taking.
The contract had a clause in it, plain as day, that made the HOA responsible for pipe repairs. Not the water company. Not the county. Not the farmers whose land the pipe crossed. The HOA. That was the deal. They got the water, and in return they kept the pipe in repair. It was written in the same plain language as the rest of the agreement, and Melissa read it out loud to me twice, slowly, so there could be no mistake about what it said.
But Karen had collected maintenance fees from the residents for years. Every household in Briar Ridge paid a monthly fee, and part of that fee was marked, on the statements, for pipe maintenance. I saw copies of those statements. They were neat and professional, with the Briar Ridge logo at the top and a line item that said, in plain English, pipeline maintenance. The residents paid it, month after month, year after year, because they believed the money was going to keep the pipe in repair. They believed that when a section of pipe rusted or a joint leaked or a valve wore out, their money would pay to fix it.