I did not move anything. I stood in the middle of the secret room, and I looked at Lily's dollhouse, and I thought about Lily, four years old, sitting on her bedroom rug with a peanut butter sandwich, feeding a little girl through a wall. And I thought about Emma, five years old, living in a room twenty-six by twenty-six feet, with metal discs and X's on the walls, and a dollhouse in the middle, and I thought about how small she must have felt in a room that big, and how big that room must have felt when you were five years old and alone in the dark.
Harris pointed to the far wall, and I followed her finger, and that was when I saw the hearts.
There were three small red hearts, painted or drawn on the wall in a neat row, each one about the size of a child's hand. They were not perfect hearts. They were the kind of hearts a child draws, a little lopsided, one side higher than the other, the red faded in places where small fingers had touched them again and again. They were low on the wall, at the height of a child standing on the floor, and they had been drawn with care, each one separate, each one its own.
And on the wall beside them, larger, drawn in a different hand, was another red heart shape. It was bigger, steadier, made by an adult, and it curved around the three small hearts like an arm around a shoulder.
"Three hearts," Harris said quietly. "Do you know what they mean?"
I did not answer. I was already walking toward them, and the closer I got, the more I could see. The three small hearts were not identical. One was drawn in a deep red, pressed hard into the wall, as if the child who drew it had wanted it to last. One was drawn lighter, the lines thinner, as if the child had been afraid of making a mistake. And one was drawn in a red that had faded to a soft pink, the oldest of the three, and it had been touched so many times that the center of it was worn smooth.
I put my hand near them, not touching, just close enough to feel the wall, and I thought about whose hands had made them. Emma, Lily, and Rose. Three small red hearts. Emma, five years old, hidden in the wall. Lily, four years old, feeding her through a vent. And Rose, my mother, the grandmother who had hidden Emma first, who had sung the old hymn when she was nervous, who had died four years ago and left a house with two hearts.
"Emma, Lily, Rose," I said. It was not a question. It was the only answer that made sense. Three small red hearts, one for each of them. Three lives, joined together in a secret room, marked on a wall in red paint, the way a child marks the things she loves so she will not forget them.
Harris nodded. "We will photograph them," she said. "We will not paint over them. We will not touch them."
I turned away from the hearts and looked at the rest of the room, and that was when I saw Emma's things. They were arranged in a corner, on a low shelf and on the floor beside it, the way a child arranges the few things she owns when she has very little and wants to keep it all in sight. There were small clothes, folded neatly. There was a blanket, thin and worn, folded into a square. There was a cup, a plastic cup with a chipped rim, and a small plate. There was a hairbrush with dark hairs still caught in it. And there was a doll.
The doll was lying on its side, its dress smoothed flat, its arms arranged carefully across its chest, as if someone had tucked it in for the night. And the doll was missing one eye.
I knew that doll. I had seen it in Emma's arms the night she crawled out of the wall, hugging it against her chest while she whispered, "Daddy?" I had seen the empty socket where the eye should have been, and I had not understood what it meant. Now I understood. The doll had lived in this room with her. The doll had been her companion in the dark. The doll was missing one eye, and Emma had kept it anyway, and she had loved it anyway, and she had carried it out of the wall with her when she finally came into the light.
"That is her doll," I said. "She had it with her. The night she came out."
Harris looked at the doll, and her face did not change, but she was quiet for a long time. "We will take it as evidence," she said. "But we will be careful with it. It matters."
I stood in the secret room, and I looked at the three small red hearts, and I looked at the doll missing one eye, and I thought about the house I had lived in for years, the house with two hearts, and I understood something I had not understood before. The house had not been hiding Emma from me. The house had been keeping her alive. The walls had held her. The room had held her. The hearts on the wall had held her. And now the house was giving her back, one piece at a time, the way a person gives back the things they have kept safe for a very long time.
I turned to Harris. "What else is in here?" I said.