"I don't know," Megan said softly. "I don't know what happened to your mother. I know your father was capable of terrible things. I know he took children from their mothers. I know he had me locked away. I know he had papers signed that were not true. But I don't know whether he killed her. And I don't want to say that he did, until we know."
Julia nodded. She wiped her eyes with the back of her hand, and she said, "I know. I know we don't know yet. But I did. I felt it. When she died, I felt it. And I was sixteen, and I was scared, and I didn't say anything, and now she's gone, and I can't ask her."
"You don't have to ask her," I said. "You don't have to know yet. Harris is looking. They're exhuming the records first. Then possibly her body. If there is an answer, they will find it. And if there isn't an answer, then we will live with not knowing. But we will live with it together."
Julia looked at me, and she looked at Megan, and she nodded, slowly, and she let go of the table, and she folded her hands in her lap, and the cabin was quiet again, except for the fire in the stove and the water moving against the shore outside.
That night, I thought about what Julia had said. Some truths arrive before proof. I thought about my mother, and I thought about my father, and I thought about the doctor, and I thought about the papers, and I thought about how much we did not know, and how much we might never know. And I thought about the fact that not knowing was itself a kind of truth, a hard truth, a truth that would sit with us for a long time, in a small cabin by a lake, while the police opened files and the clerks spoke and the old cases were reviewed, one by one, and the families were counted, dozens of them, maybe more.
We don't know yet. That was the answer. That was the only answer we had. And it would have to be enough, for now.
That night, after the girls had gone to bed, Lily came out of the bedroom in her nightdress, rubbing her eyes, and stood in the doorway of the main room, looking at us.
She had been asleep, or she had been pretending to be asleep, and now she was awake, and she was standing there in the doorway, small and barefoot on the wooden floor, with her hair falling over her face, and she looked at the three of us sitting at the table, and she could see, even at four years old, that something was wrong.
"Why are the adults sad?" she asked.
It was a simple question. It was the kind of question a child asks when she sees something she does not understand, and she asks it plainly, without fear, because she has not yet learned to be afraid of the answers. Why are the adults sad? She had seen us sitting at the table, quiet, with cold tea in our cups, and she had seen Julia gripping the table, and she had seen Megan staring out the window, and she had heard the names, Dr. Leonard Graves, and the words, exhuming records, and possibly her body, and she had understood, in the way children understand, that the grown-ups were carrying something heavy.
Megan looked at her. She did not look away. She did not try to smile. She just looked at her daughter, the small girl standing in the doorway, and she said, very gently, "Because some people told very big lies."
Lily thought about that. She stood in the doorway, rubbing her eyes, and she thought about it, the way she thought about everything, seriously, with her whole face, and then she said, "But we found Emma."
It was not a question. It was a statement. A fact. A small, solid fact, in a world full of lies. We found Emma. Emma had been hidden in a wall, and Lily had fed her sandwiches through a vent, and one day her father had smashed the wall open, and Emma had come out, and now she was here, in a cabin by a lake, with a basket for emergency snacks beside her bed, and a sister who had knocked on every wall, and a mother who was learning how to touch her again.
Megan looked at Lily, and I saw her face change, just slightly, the way a face changes when someone says something true and simple, and you realise that the truth has been there all along, underneath everything else.
"Yes," Megan said.
Lily nodded, satisfied, as if that settled it. The adults were sad because some people had told very big lies. But we found Emma. That was the other side of it. That was the part that mattered. The lies had been big, but the truth had been bigger, or at least it had been strong enough, or at least it had been found, by a four-year-old girl with a peanut butter sandwich, and a father who had heard a sound in a wall, and a grandmother who had left a letter in a metal box, and a detective who had not stopped asking questions.
Lily walked across the main room, barefoot on the wooden floor, and she went down the hallway to the bedroom, and she climbed into the bed where Emma was sleeping, and she took Emma's hand in hers, and she held it, and she looked back at us, standing in the doorway of the bedroom, and she said it, the way a child says something she knows is true, the way she had said "No people" when she knocked on every wall, plainly and without doubt.
Lily took Emma's hand. "Then one big truth too."