If I die suddenly. She had known. She had known something was wrong. She had known that her husband was not done taking children. She had hidden Emma. She had left tapes and documents. She had warned me, in a letter, from beyond the grave, not to trust my father's grief.
And now a doctor named Leonard Graves had signed her death certificate. And the police were going to exhume the records first. Then possibly her body.
I did not sleep that night. I lay awake, listening to the cabin, listening to the lake, listening to the silence, and I thought about my mother, and I thought about the doctor, and I thought about the papers, and I thought about how many signatures it took to steal a family.
That evening, after Harris had gone, Julia gripped the table.
We were sitting in the main room of the cabin, the five of us, or the four of us, because the girls were in the bedroom, playing quietly, and the adults were at the table, and the tea had gone cold in our cups, and nobody had said anything for a long time. The light was fading over the lake. The police car was still at the end of the road. The stove was warm. And then Julia put both hands flat on the table, and she gripped the edge of it, hard, so hard that her knuckles went white, and she said the words none of us had been willing to say out loud.
"Dad killed Mom?"
The question hung in the air of the small cabin, and it did not go away. It sat there between us, on the table, like something heavy that had been put down and could not be picked up again.
I looked at Julia. She was twenty-two years old, and she had been sixteen when it happened, sixteen when our father told her that if she said anything, he would have her committed like Megan, and she had carried that fear with her for six years, and now she was sitting at a table in a cabin by a lake, gripping the wood with both hands, asking the question that had been growing inside her ever since she learned the truth about what our father had done.
"We don't know yet."
It was the only honest answer I had. We did not know. We knew that Dr. Leonard Graves had signed my mother's death certificate, and that the same doctor had signed Megan's false evaluations. We knew that my father had reported my mother's death, and that there might never have been an autopsy, and that my mother had warned me not to trust my father's grief. We knew that my mother had hidden Emma, and that she had left tapes and documents, and that she had been afraid. But we did not know how she had died. We did not know whether our father had killed her. We did not know whether the doctor had helped him, or whether the doctor had simply signed a paper he was told to sign, or whether my mother had died of something ordinary, in a house full of secrets, and our father had simply used her death the way he had used everything else, as a cover, as a silence, as a way to keep the truth buried.
"We don't know yet." I said it again, because it was important to say it twice, because it was important that Julia heard it, and that I heard it, and that Megan heard it.
Julia did not let go of the table. She looked at me, and her eyes were wet, and she said, "But I did."
I waited. I did not know what she meant. I thought she meant that she knew, that she had known all along, that she had seen something, or heard something, when she was sixteen, and that she had carried it with her, and that now she was finally saying it. But she did not say anything else. She just looked at me, and she gripped the table, and she said it again, quieter this time, like a confession.
"But I did. Some truths arrive before proof."
Some truths arrive before proof. I sat at the table, and I let those words settle over me, and I understood what she meant. She meant that she had felt it, in her bones, in the years since our mother died, in the way our father had acted, in the way he had silenced her, in the way he had threatened her, in the way the house had felt after our mother was gone. She meant that a daughter knows, sometimes, before anyone can prove it. She meant that the truth does not always wait for paperwork, or for a signature, or for an exhumation. Sometimes the truth arrives first, quiet and certain, and the proof comes later, or it does not come at all, and you are left holding a truth you cannot prove, in a house by a lake, with your hands gripping a table.
Megan reached across the table and put her hand over Julia's hand. Julia did not pull away. She let Megan's hand rest on hers, and she took a slow breath, and she loosened her grip on the table, just a little, and she looked down at their hands, together on the wood.