She said it plainly, the way a child says a plain truth, and I heard it, and I understood that Julia had been sixteen years old when it happened, and she had been a child herself, and she had been afraid of her father, and she had been afraid of Claire, and she had been told that if she said anything, he would have her committed like Megan, and she had believed him, because she was sixteen and he was a judge and he was her father and she had no one to tell.
Harris took Julia into another room, and she questioned her for three hours. Three hours. I sat outside and waited, and I listened to the murmur of their voices through the door, and I thought about Julia, sixteen years old, hiding in her bedroom, listening to her father and Claire in the hallway, listening to her mother whispering through a vent, listening to a baby crying in a secret room, and saying nothing, because she was afraid, because she had been told she would be committed, because she was a child and she did not know what else to do.
When Harris came out, she told me what Julia had said.
Julia had seen the locked cabinet in the father's office. She had seen it, and she had wondered what was inside it, and she had been too afraid to open it. She had seen Claire carrying files at midnight, through the house, in the dark, carrying them from the office to the secret room, carrying them back again, and she had known that something was wrong, and she had said nothing. She had heard Rose whispering through the vent to Emma, late at night, when the house was quiet, whispering stories and songs, and then one night the whispering stopped, and Rose went silent, and Julia knew that something had happened, and she said nothing, because she was afraid.
"After her mother died, Claire found Emma," Harris said. "Julia saw it. Julia knew it. Claire found Emma in the secret room, after Rose died, and Claire kept her there. Claire kept her in the wall. Claire fed her. Claire kept her quiet. Claire kept her hidden. And Julia knew."
"Why didn't Claire kill her?" I said. "Why didn't she just... why did she keep her alive?"
Harris looked at me, and her voice was quiet, and she said what Julia had told her, word for word. "She said she couldn't let Dad's work be exposed. ... But she couldn't kill a child."
I stood in the hallway of the hospital, and I thought about Claire, and I thought about my father, and I thought about Emma, five years old, living in a wall, and I thought about a woman who could hide a child for years but could not kill her, and I thought about how strange and terrible that was, how a person could be cruel enough to lock a little girl in a wall and still not cruel enough to end her life, and how Emma had lived because of that one small mercy, that one line Claire would not cross.
Harris put her hand on my arm. "There is one more thing," she said. "Julia told us where Megan is. Or where she was last heard of. And we are going to follow it. But I want you to hear it from Julia first."
I went back into the room, and Julia was sitting on the edge of a chair, and Emma was still on the bed, and Lily was beside her, holding her hand, and the two little girls were together, one visible, one hidden, and now both visible, and I knelt down in front of my sister, and I took her hands, and I said, "Julia. Where is Megan?"
Julia looked at me. She looked at Emma. She looked at Harris. And then she said it, quietly, the way you say something you have held inside for years and are finally letting go.
"Where is Megan?" I had asked, and Julia had answered, and her answer was the only thing that mattered, the only thing that had mattered for six years, the only thing that had kept me awake at night without knowing why.
"Last I heard, Briar Hill."
Briar Hill. A private psychiatric hospital, two counties away. A place I had never heard of. A place where a woman could be kept for years, and no one would know, and no one would ask, and no one would ever come looking.
I stood up. I looked at Harris. I looked at Julia. I looked at Emma, five years old, holding her doll missing one eye, sitting on a hospital bed, waiting for someone to tell her that her mother was coming home.
And I said it, out loud, in the hospital room, with my sister and my daughters beside me, and I said it because it was true, and because it was the first true thing I had said in six years, and because it changed everything.
"Megan was alive."
Detective Harris did not telephone me. She came to the hospital in person, walking down the corridor with the same steady pace she had used in my house, and she stopped outside the room where Lily and Emma were sleeping on two narrow beds pushed close together. She looked at them for a moment through the glass, the way a person looks at something fragile that has already been broken once, and then she turned to me and said that Briar Hill had answered her.
They had denied it. Of course they had denied it. A private psychiatric hospital two counties away did not simply open its doors and hand over its records because a detective asked nicely. The woman on the telephone had been polite and firm and certain. There was no patient by the name of Megan here. There had never been a patient by the name of Megan here. The records were confidential. The hospital was private. Goodbye.