My Daughter Was Secretly Feeding a Little Girl Through Her Bedroom Wall — Then the Child Crawled Out, Pointed at Me, and Said "Daddy"

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"She's not real," Claire said. Her voice was shaking now, and she was looking at me, not at the girls. "She's not real. She's not real."

"Claire," I said, "she is real. She is sitting right here. She is a little girl. She has been living in our wall."

"No," Claire said, and she shook her head hard, like she could shake the truth out of the room. "She's not real. Lily made her up. Lily has an imaginary friend, and you are making it worse. You're scaring both of them. Ryan, you smashed a hole in our daughter's bedroom wall. Do you hear yourself? Do you know how that sounds?"

"It sounds like the truth," I said. "I saw her. I held her. She called me Dad. She is wearing my dead mother's bracelet, Claire. How do you explain that?"

Claire's mouth opened, and then it closed, and she looked at Emma's wrist, at the silver bracelet, and something flickered across her face, too fast for me to catch, and then it was gone.

"She found it," Claire said. "She must have found it somewhere. In the house. In a drawer. Children find things."

"My mother was buried with that bracelet," I said. "There was no drawer. There was a grave."

"Then I don't know," Claire said, and her voice rose. "I don't know, Ryan. I don't know how she got it, and I don't know who she is, and I don't know what Lily has been telling you, but she is not real. She can't be real. If she were real, that would mean, that would mean I, that would mean someone, oh God."

She stopped, and she put her hand over her mouth, and her eyes filled with tears, and for a moment, just a moment, I almost believed her. She looked so frightened, so lost, standing there in our kitchen in the middle of the night, that I almost wanted to believe that none of this was happening, that Emma was a dream, that the wall was whole, that Lily was asleep in her bed.

But Emma was warm against my chest, and her heartbeat was real, and her small hand was clutching my shirt, and Lily was standing on her chair, her arms out, protecting her friend.

"She's real," Lily said, her voice small but certain. "She's my friend. She's my sandwich friend. Don't let Mommy take her."

I stood up, holding Emma in my arms, and Lily climbed down from her chair and took Emma's hand, and I looked at Claire, and I said, very quietly, "Step back, Claire."

"Ryan," she said.

"Step back," I said again. "Don't touch her. Don't come near her. Not until you tell me the truth."

Claire took a step back. Her hands dropped to her sides. She looked at the three of us, and her face crumpled, and she turned away, and she put her hands over her face, and she stood there in our kitchen, shaking, while Emma hid her face in my shirt and Lily held her hand tight.

"She's not real," Claire whispered, one more time, to no one, to herself. "She's not real. She's not real."

I carried Emma back to the living room and sat down on the couch with her on my lap, and Lily curled up beside us, and Claire followed us and stood by the fireplace, her arms wrapped around herself again, her face pale in the lamplight. The house was silent around us. Outside, the street was dark and empty. Inside, everything I thought I knew about my life was coming apart, piece by piece.

"Tell me the truth," I said to Claire. "All of it. Right now."

"I don't know what you want me to say," Claire said.

"I want you to tell me who Emma is," I said. "I want you to tell me how long she has been in that wall. I want you to tell me how she got my mother's bracelet. And I want you to tell me what happened to Megan."

Claire flinched when I said Megan's name, like the name itself was a blow.

"Megan was unstable. She left her child. I protected this family." The words came out fast, practiced, like words Claire had said a hundred times before, to herself, to me, to anyone who would listen.

I stared at her. "What do you mean, she left her child? Megan left six years ago. She disappeared. You told me she walked away. You told me she was unstable and she left me and she never came back. You never told me she had a child. You never told me there was a baby."

"Because there wasn't supposed to be," Claire said. "Because she left. Because she was sick, Ryan. She was sick in her head. She heard things, she believed things that weren't true, she made accusations against people who had done nothing wrong. She left her child behind because she couldn't take care of her, and I, I did what I had to do. I protected this family."

"Protected this family?" I said. "By hiding a five-year-old girl inside a wall? By letting my four-year-old daughter feed her sandwiches through a vent? Is that what you call protection?"

"I kept her safe," Claire said, and her voice rose. "I kept her fed. I kept her hidden. You don't understand what it was like. You weren't there. You didn't see what Megan was like at the end. She was dangerous. She was going to destroy everything. Your father's name, this family, all of it. I did what I had to do."

"My father's name," I said. "What does my father have to do with this?"

Claire's mouth snapped shut. She looked away, toward the fireplace, toward the dark window, anywhere but at me.

News in the same category

My Daughter Was Secretly Feeding a Little Girl Through Her Bedroom Wall — Then the Child Crawled Out, Pointed at Me, and Said "Daddy"

45 Part