Claire was crying in the doorway now, her hand over her mouth, and Lily was standing beside me, her small hand on my arm, and I could feel both of them watching me, waiting to see what I would do.
I set the flashlight down on the floor, the beam pointing up at the ceiling, and I reached both hands into the hole I had smashed in the wall. The edges of the drywall were rough and sharp, and plaster dust fell on my arms, and the little girl flinched again when my hands came close, pressing herself flat against the wooden beam, the teddy bear held up between us like it could protect her.
I could not make sense of what I was seeing. A little girl, living in the hollow behind my daughter's bedroom wall. A little girl who had just called me Dad.
"It's okay," I said, and my voice was shaking. "It's okay. I'm not going to hurt you. Come here. Come out."
She did not move. She just stared at me, her big eyes full of fear and something else, something that looked almost like hope.
"Come on," Lily said from the bed. She had climbed down and come to stand beside me, and she reached her small hand into the hole. "It's okay. That's my daddy. He's nice. Come out."
The little girl looked at Lily, and something in her face softened, and she let go of the beam with one hand and took Lily's hand. Lily pulled gently, and I reached in and put my hands around the girl's waist, and I lifted her out of the wall and set her down on the rug.
She was so light. Lighter than Lily, and Lily was only four. Her ribs showed through her thin shirt when she moved. Her feet were bare and filthy. She stood there on the rug, holding the teddy bear, looking from me to Lily to Claire in the doorway, and she did not say a word.
"That's her," Lily said, pointing. "That's my sandwich friend. I told you, Daddy. I told you she was real."
I looked back into the hole. The flashlight beam moved over the hollow, over the thin blanket and the plastic cup and the crumbs, and then it caught on something lying flat against the wooden beam, half hidden under a fold of the blanket. I reached in and pulled it out.
It was a photograph. An old photograph, creased at the corners, the colors faded a little. It showed two little girls standing in a garden, side by side, holding hands. They had the same dark hair, the same big eyes, the same small smiles. They looked like twins.
I turned the photograph over. There was nothing written on the back, no names, no date, just the pale, blank paper, worn soft at the corners from being held. The two girls in the picture wore matching dresses, pale blue, and they stood in front of a fence covered in flowers, squinting a little into the sun. One of them had a small gap between her front teeth. The other had a smudge of dirt on her cheek. They looked happy. They looked like sisters who had never been apart a day in their lives, and I stood there holding that photograph in my dusty hands, looking from the picture to the little girl on the rug to Lily beside her, and my mind kept trying to make the pieces fit and failing, because the girls in the photograph were the same age, and Lily was four, and Emma was five, and none of it made sense.
I stared at the photograph, and then I stared at the little girl on the rug, and then I stared at Lily, and the two girls in the photograph looked like them, like both of them at once, and I could not understand what I was looking at.
I turned to Claire. She was still standing in the doorway, her robe pulled tight around her, her face white, her hands gripping the doorframe so hard her knuckles had gone white too.
"You hid my daughter right here in this very house?!" I said. The words came out of me before I could stop them, loud and raw, and Lily flinched, and the little girl pressed herself against my leg.
"I didn't," Claire said, but her voice was thin and weak. "Ryan, it's not what you think. I can explain. Please. Let me explain."
"Explain what?" I said. "Explain the child in the wall? Explain the photograph? Explain why my four-year-old daughter has been feeding a little girl through a vent every night while I slept down the hall?"
"She's not your daughter," Claire said, and then she stopped, and her mouth closed, and she looked at the little girl, and then at me, and something passed across her face, something I could not read.
"She called me Dad," I said.
"She doesn't know what she's saying," Claire said. "She's confused. She's been alone in there. She's not well. Ryan, please. Put her back. Let me handle this. I'll take care of it."
"Put her back?" I said. "In the wall? Are you listening to yourself?"
The little girl was holding onto my leg now, her small fingers curled into the fabric of my pants, her face pressed against my knee. Lily was holding her other hand. Two little girls, one on each side of me, both looking up at me, both trusting me to know what to do.
I reached for my phone with my free hand. My fingers were dusty from the drywall, and the screen lit up bright in the dark room.
"I'm calling the police," I said.
Claire took a step toward me, her hand reaching out. "Ryan, no. Don't. Please don't do this."