My Daughter Was Secretly Feeding a Little Girl Through Her Bedroom Wall — Then the Child Crawled Out, Pointed at Me, and Said "Daddy"

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I married Claire two years after you disappeared," I said.

I had not planned to say it. I had not planned to tell her like that, in the corridor, in the dark, with no warning. But the words were there, and they needed to be said, and I said them, and I watched her face as I said them, and her face did not change, and I knew that she had already known, or that she had guessed, or that she had prepared herself for it in the years at Briar Hill.

"I married Claire two years after you disappeared," I said again. "I thought you were gone. I thought you had left us. I thought you had left Emma. I did not know that Emma existed. I did not know that you were pregnant. I did not know any of it. And then Claire was there, and she was kind, and she was patient, and she helped me, and I married her, and we had Lily."

"That Lily was four," Megan said, and she said it softly, and she said it the way a person says a thing they have already accepted, a thing they have already made peace with, even if the peace is not complete.

"Yes," I said. "That Lily was four. She is four years old. She is my daughter. She is Emma's sister. She is the reason we found Emma. She fed her through the wall. She kept her alive. She loves her. And she loves you already, Megan, even though she has only just met you. She told me tonight that you smell like Mama, and I did not know what to say to that, because I did not know how she knew."

Megan was quiet for a moment. She looked down the corridor, towards the room where the girls were sleeping, and she said, "She is four. She is so small. She has been so brave."

"She has," I said. "They both have. Emma is five, and Lily is four, and they have been braver than any of us. They have been braver than me. I did not find Emma. Lily found her. I just broke the wall down."

Megan squeezed my hand, and she said, "You are responsible now," one more time, and this time it sounded like a beginning, and not like an ending, and I knew that she was right, and that I would be responsible now, for Emma, and for Lily, and for her, and for the truth, and for making sure that the people who had done this would answer for it, and that the children who were still out there would be found.

The next morning, before we left the hospital, I went back to the house.

I did not go inside for long. I did not need to. The police had finished their search, and the house was quiet, and the rooms were empty, and the only sound was the sound of my own footsteps on the floorboards. I walked down the corridor to Lily's bedroom, and I stood in the doorway, and I looked at the broken wall.

The hole was still there. The drywall was still smashed open, the edges ragged and white, the plaster dust still on the floor. Behind it, the hollow was dark, and the secret room was beyond it, and the metal discs and the X's were still on the walls, and the dollhouse was still in the middle of the floor, and the three small red hearts were still on the wall, Emma, Lily, Rose, and the whole house still held its breath, the way it had held its breath for five years.

I stood there, and I looked at the broken wall, and I thought about the two rooms, the room where Lily had slept, and the room where Emma had hidden, and I thought about how close they had been to each other, all that time, separated by a few inches of plaster and a lie.

Two little girls. One visible. One hidden.

That was how it had been. Lily had been visible. She had gone to school, and she had played in the garden, and she had eaten at the table, and she had been loved, and she had been seen. Emma had been hidden. She had lived in the dark, and she had eaten sandwiches through a vent, and she had whispered through a wall, and she had been loved too, in the only way she could be loved, by a grandmother who sang to her, and by a little sister who fed her, and by a mother who was two counties away and could not reach her.

I thought about Megan, and about the five years, and about the six years, and about the night she had left, and about the day she had come back, and I thought about the words she had said to me in the corridor, you are responsible now, that is different from guilty then, and I thought about Claire, sitting in her cell, and about my father, beloved, respected, dead, corrupt, and about my mother, who had hidden a child and then died, and about Julia, who had been sixteen and afraid, and about Lily, who was four, and about Emma, who was five, and I felt something rise up in my chest, something hot and sharp and old, something I had been carrying for a long time without knowing it.

I wanted to hate her.

News in the same category

My Daughter Was Secretly Feeding a Little Girl Through Her Bedroom Wall — Then the Child Crawled Out, Pointed at Me, and Said "Daddy"

45 Part