I looked down at Emma again, at her small face, peaceful in sleep, and I thought about Megan, about her dark hair and her laugh and the way she used to sing in the kitchen in the morning, and I thought about six years, and five years, and how the numbers did not add up, and how the woman standing by my fireplace had answers she would not give me.
"But Emma was five," I whispered, to myself, to the sleeping child in my arms, to the empty room. "But Emma was five."
I shifted Emma gently onto the couch, and I laid Lily down beside her, and I covered them both with the blanket from the back of the couch, and they slept on, close together, Emma's hand still curled around the teddy bear, Lily's hand resting on Emma's arm, like she was making sure her friend would still be there when she woke up.
Then I took out my phone.
Claire saw the phone in my hand, and her face changed, and she came toward me fast, her hand reaching out, and she lunged for the phone, her fingers closing around my wrist.
"Don't," she said. "Ryan, don't. Please. Don't call anyone. We can fix this. We can fix this ourselves. No one has to know."
I pulled my arm away. She lunged again, and this time her hand caught the phone, and we struggled for a second, her fingers clawing at mine, my grip tight, and then I broke free and stepped back, and I held the phone up and away from her, and I dialed.
For ten years, Claire had seen me as soft. She had seen me as the man who went along, who believed what he was told, who did not ask too many questions, who let other people decide what was true. She had seen me as soft for ten years, and she was counting on that now, counting on me to put the phone down, to let her explain it away, to go back to bed and pretend the wall was whole.
I did not put the phone down.
"911," I said into the phone, when the dispatcher answered. "My name is Ryan. I need police at my house. Right now. There is a child here. A little girl. She was hidden inside the wall of my house. She is five years old. She needs help. Please. Please send someone."
Claire stood there, her hands at her sides now, her face white, watching me, and the dispatcher's voice came through the phone, calm and steady, asking me questions, asking for the address, asking if the child was hurt, asking if anyone else was in danger, and I answered them all, my voice shaking, my eyes on the two little girls sleeping on the couch.
When I hung up, the room was silent. Claire was standing by the fireplace again, and she was crying now, quiet tears running down her face, and she looked at me, and she looked at the couch, and she looked at the broken wall down the hall, and she came toward me slowly, and she leaned in close, so close I could feel her breath on my ear, and she whispered, so softly that only I could hear it.
"If you dig this up, your father goes down too."
My father. Judge Edward Vale. Respected. Feared. Untouchable. My father, who had been dead for three years. My father, who had reported my mother's death, who had blessed my marriage to Claire, who had been the most powerful man I had ever known, and who was gone, buried, finished.
What could digging this up do to a dead man? What could a little girl in a wall do to a judge who had been in the ground for three years?
I looked at Claire, and I looked at the sleeping girls on the couch, and I looked at the silver bracelet on Emma's small wrist, and I felt the fear move through me anyway, cold and slow, like water rising in a dark room.
My father had been dead for three years. But fear moved through me anyway.
I called 911 with hands shaking so hard I almost dropped the phone twice. Emma was still pressed against my side, her thin arms locked around my waist, her face buried in my shirt. She had not let go of me since she crawled out of the wall. Lily stood a few feet away, barefoot on the rug, her hands still sticky with peanut butter. Claire stood in the doorway, very still, watching me the way a person watches a stranger break into their house.
The dispatcher asked me what the emergency was, and I did not know how to answer her in one sentence. How do you tell a stranger that your four-year-old daughter has been feeding a second little girl through the bedroom wall, that the second girl just crawled out of a hole in the drywall and called you Daddy, that she has been living inside your house for years and you never knew?
"There's a child," I said. "A little girl. She's been living in the wall of my house. I need police and an ambulance. Please hurry."
She asked for my address, and I gave it to her. She asked if the child was hurt. I looked down at Emma. Her knees were scraped. Her hair was matted. Her clothes were dirty and too small. There was a bruise on her elbow, old and yellow-green.
"She's thin," I said. "She's scared. She won't let go of me."
"Stay on the line," the dispatcher said. "Help is on the way."