I wanted to hate Megan, for leaving, for disappearing, for being gone for six years, for letting me believe the lie, for letting me marry Claire, for letting me build a life on top of her absence. I wanted to hate her for the years I had spent alone, and for the nights I had spent wondering where she was, and for the mornings I had woken up and reached for her and found an empty bed. I wanted to hate her because hating her would be easier than understanding her, and because anger is simpler than grief, and because I needed someone to blame, and she was the only person left who was still alive to blame.
I stood in front of the broken wall, and I looked at the two rooms, and I thought about hating her, and I tried to hold on to the anger, and I tried to make it stay, and it would not stay, because underneath it there was something else, something softer and truer, something that had been there all along, underneath the anger and the grief and the six years of silence.
I could not hate her. I had tried, and I could not. I had wanted to, and I had stood in front of the wall and I had wanted to, and the wanting was real, and the anger was real, and the grief was real, but the hate was not real, because she had not left me, not really, not the way they had told me she had left. She had been taken. She had been hidden. She had been locked away in a white room two counties away, and she had asked them to tell no one, because she was afraid, and she had waited, for five years, for someone to find her, and I had found her, and now she was here, and Emma was here, and Lily was here, and we were a family again, or we were becoming one, and there was no room in any of that for hate.
I put my hand on the broken wall, on the ragged edge of the plaster, and I felt the dust on my fingers, and I thought about the house, and about the two hearts it had held, and about the two little girls, one visible and one hidden, and about the woman who had been a wife and a mother and a nurse and a patient and a woman, and about the man I had been, and the man I was going to have to be now, and I stood there for a long time, until the light changed in the window, and the house was quiet, and the wall was still broken, and the truth was still there, in the open, where everyone could see it.
I wanted to hate her.
But I wanted to.
The house became evidence.
That was what Detective Harris said to me on the morning we left it, and the words stayed in my head for a long time after, turning over and over like something I had found in a drawer and could not put back. The house became evidence. Not a home. Not the place where my daughter had learned to walk, where my mother had sung in the kitchen, where I had once believed I knew who everyone in my family was. Evidence. A thing to be measured and photographed and sealed, room by room, wall by wall.
We could not return.
That was the other thing she said, and she said it plainly, the way she said most things, without softening it. "You can't go back there, Mr. Ryan. Not while the search is ongoing. Not while the case is open." She did not say for how long. She did not say whether we would ever go back. She said the house would be searched again, more slowly this time, every wall, every floor, every space that had been built to hide something, and that no one who lived there could be inside while that happened.
Not with the girls.
I understood that part without her having to explain it. Lily was four years old. Emma was five. They had already lived inside a house that had two hearts, a house that had kept one of them in a wall and told the other one to keep quiet about it. They could not sleep one more night in a place where every wall was a question. Lily still looked at walls the way other children looked at dogs they did not trust. She would walk past a wall and slow down, her eyes moving along it, waiting for it to speak.
Not with Megan.
Megan had been gone from that house for six years, and she had never really lived in it as it was now. The house she had known was the house of my parents, the house where my mother had hidden her long enough to give birth to a child, the house where my father had signed papers that took that child away. The house that stood there now, with Claire's curtains and Claire's furniture and Claire's locked cabinet in my father's old office, was not a house Megan could come back to. It was the house that had kept her daughter in a wall and called her unstable.
So we packed in the morning, in a hurry, with the police waiting outside and a woman from the department standing in the hallway with a clipboard, writing down what we took. Clothes for the girls. Lily's shoes. Emma's new clothes, the ones the hospital had given her, because she had almost nothing of her own. The teddy bear. The doll missing one eye. I did not want to take the doll. I thought about leaving it there, in the room where it had lived, in the dark behind the wall. But Emma held it against her chest while we packed, and she would not let go of it, so it came with us.