"Claire," I said. "What does my father have to do with Megan?"
"He was a judge," Claire said, quietly. "He knew people. He knew what Megan was saying about him, about the court. She was making accusations. She was unstable. He was worried about her. We were all worried about her."
I looked down at Emma. She had fallen asleep against my chest, her breathing slow and even now, the teddy bear still clutched in her arms, her small hand curled around my shirt. Lily was asleep too, her head on my shoulder, her thumb in her mouth the way she did when she was tired. Two little girls, asleep on me, trusting me, and I was sitting in the middle of a lie I had been living in for years without knowing it.
"When did you find her?" I asked Claire. "When did you find Emma in the wall?"
Claire was quiet for a long time. The clock on the wall ticked. The house creaked around us, the old wood settling in the night.
"I didn't find her," Claire said at last, her voice very small. "I knew she was there. I always knew."
The words hung in the air between us, heavy and cold.
"You always knew," I said.
"Yes," Claire said. "I always knew."
I sat there on the couch with two sleeping little girls in my arms, and I started to count. I counted the years the way you count on your fingers when the numbers will not sit still in your head.
Megan disappeared six years ago. Six years. I remembered the day. I remembered coming home and finding her things still in the closet and her car still in the driveway and her gone, just gone, and Claire, who had been my friend then, who had worked as my father's clerk, telling me that Megan had left, that she was unstable, that she had walked away from her life and from me, and that I should let her go.
I married Claire two years after Megan disappeared. Two years. Lily was born after that. Lily was four now. Four years old, sitting on the rug in her bedroom, feeding sandwiches through a vent to a little girl in the wall.
I thought back to those two years, the empty years after Megan went, when I had walked around my own house like a stranger, when I had called her phone a hundred times and gotten nothing, when I had gone to the police and they had told me there was nothing to find, that adults were allowed to leave, that she had probably just needed a new life. Claire had been there through all of it, steady and kind, bringing food, sitting with me, telling me that Megan had been unwell for a long time, that she had seen the signs, that the kindest thing I could do was accept it and move on. I had leaned on her. I had trusted her completely. And then, two years later, I had married her, and my father, the judge, had given us his blessing, and everyone had said how good it was that I had found someone steady, someone who understood our family.
And Emma was five.
Five. I looked down at her sleeping face, at her dark hair and her small hands and the silver bracelet on her wrist, and I counted again, and the numbers would not fit together.
If Megan had left when Emma was born, if Emma was Megan's daughter, then Emma would be six. Six years since Megan disappeared. But Emma was five.
"Megan disappeared six years ago," I said to Claire, and my voice was very quiet, because the girls were sleeping, and because I was afraid of what I was about to say. "Emma is five years old. Five. Not six. Five."
Claire said nothing. She stood by the fireplace, her arms around herself, her eyes on the floor.
"So when was she born?" I asked. "When did Megan have this child? If Megan left six years ago, and Emma is five, then Megan was pregnant when she left, or she had the baby after she left, or she didn't leave when you told me she left. Which is it, Claire?"
"I don't know," Claire said. "I don't know the exact dates. It was a long time ago. You're asking me to remember things from years ago, in the middle of the night, when I'm, when I'm not thinking straight."
"You knew she was in the wall," I said. "You always knew. So you know when she was born. You know when Megan had her. Tell me."
Claire shook her head. "It doesn't matter when she was born. What matters is that Megan left her. What matters is that I took care of her. What matters is that this family stayed together."
"This family?" I said. "What family, Claire? A family with a child hidden in a wall? A family built on a lie about a woman who disappeared? You told me Megan was unstable. You told me she left her child. You told me you protected this family. But you hid my daughter in a wall, Claire. You hid her for years. You let a four-year-old feed her through a vent."
"She was safe," Claire said, and there were tears in her voice now. "She was safe in there. No one could hurt her. No one could take her. I made sure she had food. I made sure Lily knew to feed her. I did the best I could."
"The best you could," I said. "Emma is five years old, Claire. She has lived in a wall. She doesn't know what a kitchen table is. She eats like someone who is afraid the food will be taken away. And you are telling me you did the best you could."