She looked at me for a long moment, her big eyes studying my face, and then she said, very softly, "I'm Emma."
"Emma," I said. "That's a beautiful name."
She nodded, just once, and she held the teddy bear a little tighter.
"Emma, how old are you?" I asked.
She held up one hand and spread her fingers wide. Five. She was five years old.
"Five," I said. "And you've been living in the wall?"
She nodded again. "A long time," she said. "Since I was little."
"Who put you in there, Emma?"
She looked down at the teddy bear. "Grandma Rose hid me first," she said. "Then Mama went sleepy. Then I stayed."
Grandma Rose. My mother again. My mother, dead four years, had hidden this child first. The words did not make sense, and yet the bracelet on Emma's wrist said they were true, or at least that something true was underneath them.
"Emma," I said, and I tried to keep my voice calm and gentle, "why did you call me Dad?"
She looked up at me, and her face was very serious, the way a child's face gets when they are telling you something they believe with their whole heart.
"Because Mama said you were," she said. "My daddy?"
The words hit me like a physical blow. I sat back in my chair. My hands were flat on the table, and I could feel the wood under my palms, solid and real, and I held on to that, because everything else in the room had just come loose.
"Mama said I was your daddy?" I said.
"Yes," Emma said. "She told me. She said, your daddy lives in this house, and he will find you one day. She said, when he finds you, you say, Daddy, and he will know you."
I looked at Claire. She was staring at the table, not at me, not at Emma, and her face had gone hard, like a door closing.
"Claire," I said. "What is she talking about?"
Claire did not answer. She just stood there by the counter, her arms wrapped around herself, and I could see her jaw working, like she was chewing on words she did not want to say.
"Emma," I said, turning back to the little girl, "where is your mama? Where did she go when she went sleepy?"
"I don't know," Emma said. "She was here, and then she wasn't. Grandma Rose said Mama had to go away. She said Mama would come back, but she didn't."
"Did your mama have dark hair?" I asked. "Like yours? Like mine?"
Emma nodded. "Like mine," she said. "She sang to me. In the wall. She sang through the little holes, so I wouldn't be scared."
My chest tightened. Megan. My first wife. Megan had dark hair, and she sang, and she had disappeared six years ago, and I had not known, I had never known, that she had been carrying a child. I could see her in my mind, standing at the kitchen counter in the morning, humming while she made coffee, her dark hair tied back, sunlight coming through the window. I could see the day I came home and found her gone, her coat still on the hook, her car still in the driveway, her phone on the kitchen table, and nothing else, no note, no explanation, just an empty house and a silence that never went away. Claire had come to me that week, Claire who had worked as my father's clerk, Claire who had known Megan and me both, and she had told me, gently, that Megan was unstable, that she had been struggling for a long time, that she had walked away from her life and I should let her go. I had believed her. I had believed her because I was grieving and because I wanted someone to tell me what had happened, and Claire had an answer, and the answer was simple, and I had taken it and built my life on it.
I had married Claire two years after Megan vanished, and I had built a new life, and Lily had come, and I had thought the past was finished, buried, done.
And all this time, my daughter had been living inside the wall of my house.
Emma slid off her chair and came around the table to me, and she climbed up onto my lap, and she put her arms around my neck, and she pressed her face against my shirt, and I could feel her heartbeat through the thin fabric, fast and small and warm. I put my arms around her, gently, so gently, and I held her there, and Lily climbed up too, and she put her arms around both of us, and the three of us sat there at the kitchen table in the middle of the night, holding on to each other.
"My daddy?" Emma whispered against my shirt.
"Yes," I said, and my voice broke on the word. "Yes, sweetheart. I'm here."
We stayed like that for a long time, the three of us at the kitchen table, and I did not want to move, because moving meant going back to the questions, and the questions were going to break everything open. But Claire moved first. She came away from the counter, and she walked toward the table, and she reached out her hands toward Emma.
"Come here," she said, her voice sharp and high. "Come here, right now. You've caused enough trouble."
Emma flinched and buried her face deeper into my shirt. Lily let go of me and stood up on her chair, and she pointed at Claire, and her small face was furious.
"Don't let Mommy take her!" Lily shouted. "Daddy, don't let Mommy take her!"