Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Derek Whitmore had been a Portland police officer for fifteen years, and his personnel file, when it was finally laid open on the table of the internal review, was the thickness of a man's working life: commendations in the early years, two of them for the same winter, when he had gone into a flooded underpass after a driver and been written up in language that embarrasses everyone involved by now; training records; evaluations that used the word solid the way evaluations do when they mean a man who shows up; a transfer history that moved him around the precincts at intervals that, read in sequence, suggested a pattern no one had ever said aloud, which is that Derek Whitmore was a man whom supervisors liked at a distance of about three years. He had a marriage that had ended. He had a daughter in another state who called at Christmas. He had a house with a boat in the drive that had not been in the water in four seasons. He was, in the taxonomy of his profession, unremarkable, and it was precisely his unremarkableness that the file, read whole, indicted: because a file is not only a record of a man, it is a record of every decision the institution made about him, and the decisions in Whitmore's file had a shape.

Three times in fifteen years, complaints about Derek Whitmore had crossed a threshold that required a supervisor to write something down, and three times the something that was written down was the same word: counseling. The word appeared in the file the way a rubber stamp appears, identical each time, and the signature beneath it, each time, belonged to Lieutenant Robert Sandoval, who had been Whitmore's lieutenant across two of those precinct assignments, in the way that men rise together through an institution and carry their arrangements with them.

The first complaint, nine years old, came from a traffic stop on the east side. A driver, stopped for a broken taillight, had been addressed by Whitmore in terms that the driver, a Somali immigrant who had been a citizen for a decade and who drove a bus for the transit authority, recorded on the complaint form in careful, furious English. The driver had not been arrested. He had been told, in the course of a stop that lasted eleven minutes, several things about the country he was in and the manner in which he might consider returning to the one he had left. The complaint had been investigated in the limited sense that Whitmore had been asked about it, and Whitmore had said the driver had been argumentative, and the file recorded that the matter had been resolved by counseling, and the counseling, as described in Sandoval's memorandum, had consisted of a conversation about perception and professionalism, and there the matter rested, in the file, for nine years, waiting for the rest of the file to be written.

The second complaint, six years old, was its sibling. A detained driver this time, handcuffed in the back of the car on a warrant matter that was later found to be a clerical error belonging to another man of a similar name. The driver, a Black man of sixty-one who worked nights cleaning offices downtown, had complained that Whitmore, driving him to the precinct on the error, had entertained himself on the journey with observations about the driver's neighborhood, the driver's presumed occupation in the informal economy, and the driver's likely familiarity with the building they were driving to. The warrant error was discovered at the precinct desk. The man was released with an apology from the desk sergeant that was, by all accounts, genuine. His complaint about the journey, however, traveled its own road, and arrived, as the first had, at a memorandum from Lieutenant Sandoval recording that the officer had been counseled regarding citizen contact and that the matter was closed. No discipline. No notation that survived into any evaluation. Counseling: a conversation, unrecorded, unverifiable, leaving no trace except the word itself, filed.

News in the same category

Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

45 Part