Simone was aware of being watched over, and bore it the way she bore the protective detail, which had thinned by August to a drive-by rhythm and a phone number she did not call. Edith Harmon brought tomatoes, and then, as the summer turned, a jar of the jam she made from the plums of the tree that overhung both their fences, and she delivered these things with the briskness of a woman who will not be thanked at length. The Trans came by with their baby, who had been born the previous winter and was at the fence-sitting stage, and was presented to Simone over the fence with the ceremony due to royalty, and Simone held the baby in her gardening clothes and felt the whole improbable architecture of her life -- the robe, the court, the mud, the cameras, the file with its doors -- settle for a moment into the simple weight of a child who did not care about any of it. David Okafor fixed her mower when it died in September, refusing payment with the offended dignity of a man whose driveway had been a witness, and stayed for lemonade on the porch, and talked about the docks, and about his own daughter in Tacoma, and did not mention the afternoon at all until he was leaving, when he said, from the bottom of the steps, that he had sharpened the mower blade too, no charge, and that the street was glad she was keeping the house. Simone said she had not decided. Okafor looked at the gutters, the furnace man's truck having just left, the pruned roses, the porch step she would not fix, and he said, with the air of a man entering a finding, that the street had decided, and went home to his dinner.
She had not decided. That was the truth she kept in her own record, in the memorandum-keeping part of her mind. But she had stopped correcting people, and she had started, in September, to do a thing she had not done since she was a girl: she left a bag of her own clothes at the house, in her old room, against the weekends. And when the first rain of the fall came, in the middle of a court week, she found herself driving across the river in the dark not to the condominium with its doorman and its view, but to the house, to check the basement the way her mother had always checked the basement when the rains began, and she stood in the doorway of the basement stairs with a flashlight, listening to the house tick and settle around her, and understood that the deciding had happened the way the important decisions in her life had always happened: not in the moment of signature, but in the accumulation of Saturdays, and that the signature, when it came, would only be the record catching up with the fact.
People who met Simone Ellis after she became a judge tended to assume that the robe had been the destination of a straight road, and she rarely corrected them, because the correction took longer than the assumption and because she had learned that other people's simplifications of her life were a kind of weather. The road had not been straight. She had gone to law school because a teacher at her high school, a woman named Mrs. Abernathy who taught civics with the fervor of a revivalist, had told her that she argued like a person who intended to be paid for it, and because her father, the machinist, had said at the kitchen table that the law was a trade like any other trade except that you worked with cleaner tools, and that a person who could learn it should. She had been a prosecutor for six years, in the years when the county's drug docket was a river that never lowered, and she had been good at it in the ways that matter and troubled by it in the ways that mattered more. She had tried cases against men she believed guilty and men she believed desperate, and she had learned the prosecutor's central skill, which is the management of certainty, and she had learned its central danger, which is the same. She had left, in her early thirties, for defense work -- a defection that her old office received the way families receive a daughter's unsuitable marriage -- because she had come to believe that she could not know what the law was until she had stood on both sides of its well, and for eight years she had stood on the other side, in the well's other light, defending the accused in the same courtrooms, before the same judges, and learning the second trade's central skill, which is the management of doubt.