Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

In November, the bureau announced the formation of a working group. The announcement was a press release of the kind that institutions issue when a file has become too large to be only a file: the working group would review the bureau's practices in three areas -- the handling of repeat calls at a single address, the supervision of officers with multiple citizen complaints, and the auditing of body-worn camera compliance -- and would report to the chief in the new year. The press release did not mention the Ellis address, or the officer, or the judge, or the hose. It did not need to. Every journalist in the city wrote the story with the video embedded in it, and the working group's three areas were read, by everyone who read them, as the three roads that the file had surveyed: the log that had not been read, the stamp that had said counseling, the button that had been pressed for a sustained count of seconds in a June yard. The bureau's statement said that the review was forward-looking. The file, which was not forward-looking but was very patient, noted the announcement and its date, and went on being what it was.

The working group was real, as such things go. It had a charter and a membership and a schedule of meetings, and among its members, appointed for their expertise and their distance from the matter, was a retired judge of the state court, a woman of seventy with a reputation for reading everything, who approached the dispatch data the way she had approached records for forty years. It was she who asked, at the second meeting, for the bureau's numbers on repeat addresses: how many addresses in the city had generated five or more calls from a single caller in a season, and what the outcomes had been, and whether the system flagged them, and if it flagged them, to whom the flag was shown, and at what moment in the life of a call the showing occurred. The numbers, when they came, were the numbers of a large city: hundreds of addresses, thousands of calls, outcomes ranging from the tragic to the farcical, and a flagging system that existed, technically, in the software the bureau had purchased, and that had never been switched on, because switching it on required a policy, and the policy required a decision, and the decision had been pending, in the way of such decisions, since the software was installed. The retired judge wrote the sentence in the working group's minutes that would be quoted, later, in the report: that the bureau had possessed, for six years, a machine for noticing what it had failed to notice in June, and had kept the machine in its box. The minutes were a public record. The machine, by the end of the year, had been switched on -- a settings change, a line of configuration, an afternoon's work for a technician -- and the first flags it raised, in its first month of operation, concerned eleven addresses, at none of which, the file noted with its customary neutrality, anything had yet happened.

None of this concluded anything. That was the discipline of the season, and Simone, who watched it from across the river with a litigant's knowledge and a judge's training, understood the discipline better than the commentators did. The internal investigation remained open, its interviews complete, its findings unwritten, because a finding is a door that closes and the bureau was not ready to close doors while the district attorney's door stood open across the river, and the district attorney's review remained a review, its binder read and flagged and joined by the civil file's growing transcripts, because prosecutors, like judges, understand that the order in which doors close determines what the corridor finally looks like. The civil case ground forward through its discovery, toward a trial date that the magistrate had set, with his legendary patience, for the following spring, a date that everyone involved understood to be less a destination than a pressure. Whitmore remained on leave, his pay status adjusted by the formulas of his contract, his boat under its cover in the drive, his deposition continued to the new year. Keller remained on the night shift, in the solo car, his statement still the second document in every binder it entered. Lindqvist remained across the street, behind his blinds, his one communication to the matter a two-page letter in another man's prose. Sandoval remained a lieutenant, recused and unrebuked, his three memoranda now read by more people than had read anything he had written in thirty-one years.

News in the same category

Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

45 Part