The union provided him with a lawyer, as the union provides lawyers, out of the dues of twenty years: a man named Gerald Foss, silver-haired and unhurried, who had represented officers in difficulty since before Keller was born and who carried himself with the serenity of a man who has never once, in a long career, been surprised by a document. Foss came to the house on the third day. He did not ask Whitmore what had happened. He asked, instead, what existed. There was a difference, and Foss's whole practice lived in the difference. What existed, when they had inventoried it together at the kitchen table -- the camera, said Foss, and waited; the partner's camera, said Foss, and waited; the phones, said Foss, and Whitmore, who was not a stupid man, understood that his lawyer was teaching him the shape of the world as it now stood, in which the afternoon no longer belonged to the people who had been present at it but to the recordings of it, which could be played in any order, at any speed, in any room, forever. Foss advised him, in the calm of a man reading a weather report, that he would make no statement, give no interview, attend no meeting without counsel, and view no materials, because viewing materials creates a record of viewing, and records, as Whitmore of all men should now appreciate, are forever. Whitmore asked the question that his whole life had narrowed to, which was how bad it was. Foss considered the question with professional care. He said that in his experience there were afternoons an officer could come back from and afternoons an officer could not, and that the distinguishing feature was rarely the afternoon itself. It was the paper. He said the paper here was extensive. He said that Whitmore should prepare himself, over the coming months, to be patient, and to be quiet, and to let the process do what processes do, which was, mostly, to take a long time and to conclude nothing in public until it concluded everything at once. Then he drank the coffee Whitmore had made him and left, and the house was quiet in a way it had not been quiet before, because Whitmore's silences had previously been the silences of a man between shifts, and were now the silences of a man between identities.
His statement, when it came, came the way Foss intended everything to come: in writing, once, and through counsel. It was four paragraphs long. It stated that Officer Whitmore had responded to a reported burglary in progress at an address with which he was familiar from prior calls. It stated that he had encountered an uncooperative individual in the yard who had refused lawful commands. It stated that in the course of the encounter he had employed a garden hose found at the scene to gain compliance, a decision which, in retrospect and with the benefit of information not available to him at the time, he regretted. It stated that he had at no time known the individual's identity or occupation, and that upon learning them he had immediately desisted. It expressed his respect for the judiciary. It did not contain the laughing. It did not contain the sentence he had spoken over the water, which it did not quote, or paraphrase, or acknowledge by the space it left around itself. It did not contain the camera, whose deactivation was described in a separate sentence, in a separate paragraph, as inadvertent, a malfunction of handling during a dynamic encounter. It was, as a document, a small masterpiece of its genre, and everyone who read it in the file read it the way you read a wall built across a road: as a fact, as an obstacle, and as an admission that the road had once run where the wall now stood.
The criminal referral went across the river in September, in a binder, with a cover memorandum from the bureau that summarized the investigation's findings in the flat language of findings and attached the exhibits in order. The district attorney's office acknowledged receipt in a letter of three sentences, assigned the matter a number of its own, and said, in the manner of prosecutors' offices since the invention of the form, that the matter was under review. Under review it stayed. The referral asked the questions that referrals ask -- whether the detention had been lawful, whether the force had been criminal, whether the camera's deactivation constituted the tampering that the statute described -- and the binder contained everything the district attorney would need to answer them, and the district attorney's office, which had its own calendars and its own weather, made no answer within the season. The file noted the referral's pendency the way it noted everything: without emphasis, in sequence, a door left open in a corridor of doors.