Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The deposition ended at four o'clock, with the light going. Simone signed nothing that day; the transcript would come to her for review, errata, the small corrections of a record being made perfect. She walked out of the building with Rebecca into the November street, where the rain had paused and the bridges were lit, and Rebecca said that she had been, if the client would forgive the professional assessment, a devastating witness. Simone said that she had been a witness. The distinction, they agreed, walking, was the whole of the case.

Inspector Castellanos came back in October, to the courthouse this time, with the updated file and the recommendations of the Marshals Service set out in the orderly prose of her profession. The threat assessment had run its course. The letters that had arrived over the summer -- the kind ones and the other kind -- had been assessed, and the other kind had been found, in the main, to be the work of people whose threat was their stationery: loud, specific about the video, and empty of intent in every way that the assessors were trained to weigh. Two had been referred onward, out of caution, to offices in other states, where they had joined files of their own. No defendant of Simone's, past or present, had written anything. No organization had adopted her. The danger that the service had organized itself against in June had resolved, by October, into the ordinary weather of a public event receding: she was, the inspector said, in the formal language of the assessment, a judge whose profile had been elevated by an incident not directed at the judiciary, with no identified continuing threat stream. The protective detail, which had thinned to a rhythm by August, would now be stood down entirely, unless the judge wished otherwise.

Simone asked what the service recommended, in the long term, for the house. Castellanos, who had walked the house's street in June with the eye of her profession, gave the recommendations their due: the alarm, which Simone had already had installed; the lighting, which had been improved along the walk; the gate, at which the inspector paused, because the gate had become, in the file's margins, a kind of exhibit in the court of public record, and there are recommendations that professionals make and recommendations they make while knowing they will be declined. A new gate, the inspector said, with a lock, would be the standard advice. Simone said that the gate was hand-built by her father, that it lifted and settled, that the whole street could open it and half the street's children had, and that she intended to go on opening it the way it had been opened for fifty years. Castellanos wrote something in the file. Simone asked what she had written. The inspector, with the first unprofessional smile of their acquaintance, said that she had written that the judge had been advised and had declined, which was the form's way of respecting a decision it could not endorse. They shook hands in the chambers doorway, between the flags, in the corridor where a detail had stood all summer and now did not, and the inspector went back to her office and her other judges, and the file went into the cabinet of such files, where it would be reviewed annually and where, with luck, it would gather the dust of an uneventful decade.

The letters stayed with Simone longer than the detail had. She was not permitted to keep the originals of the assessed ones, but Rebecca had obtained, through the ordinary channels, an accounting of the kind ones, and on a night in October, in the condominium, with the river below and the first of the fall storms worrying the windows, Simone read the accounting through. There were letters from lawyers she had never met, in states she had never practiced in. There were letters from court staff -- a court reporter in Ohio, a clerk in a county courthouse in Texas, a retired marshal in Florida who wrote in a hand like a fence line. There were letters from citizens, in the proportion that citizens write to judges, which is rarely, and about matters of their own, which is usually, except that these were about hers. A woman in Georgia wrote that she had watched the video eleven times and that she had counted, each time, the seconds the judge's hands stayed down. A man in Oregon, a retired teacher, wrote that he had taught civics for thirty years and had never had a better text for the lesson about what a right is, and that he hoped she would not mind being assigned, posthumously to her privacy, to a classroom of sixteen-year-olds in Bend. A law student wrote that she had changed her summer plans because of the case and was interning with a public defender, which she offered as evidence that the video had done at least one unambiguous good in the world. Simone read them all, in order, at the kitchen counter where Castellanos had first rebuilt her file, and she answered none of them, because judges do not answer such letters, and because she did not trust her hand to be steady in the genre. But she kept the accounting, in the briefcase, in the envelope behind the memorandum she had written the first night in her mother's robe, where the two documents -- her own record of the afternoon, and the world's -- rode together, in the dark, in the order she had put them.

News in the same category

Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

45 Part