David Okafor, next door, had the third video and the strangest angle: he had come out of his garage with his phone up because the shouting had reached him through the garage's open door where he was sharpening a mower blade, and his video was taken from his own driveway, from the side, and it showed what the others could not, which was the profile of the event -- the officer's stance at the edge of the bed, the arc of the water, the woman's hands going up once, involuntarily, at the first strike of it and then coming down again and staying down, in the discipline that everyone who saw the video remarked on and no one who saw it forgot. Okafor was a retired longshoreman with a voice like a dock bell and a long memory for the street, and his statement, which ran to four pages because the investigator let him talk, contained the history of the house as the street knew it: the Ellises, the father who fixed things, the mother and her roses, the daughter who had gone off and become somebody in the law, a judge, people said, though the street had mostly experienced her as the woman who came at Christmas and shoveled her mother's walk before her own breakfast. He identified the woman in the mud without hesitation. He also identified, when asked, the thing that the file would carry forward from his statement into every summary that followed: that the officer had never once, in Okafor's hearing, asked the woman her name.
The videos traveled the way videos travel. Copies of Edith Harmon's porch video -- not the original, which sat in an evidence envelope, but a copy of a copy, filmed off a television producer's monitor or forwarded from a phone that had received it from a phone -- reached a local station on the third day, and from the station to the wider weather of the internet by the fourth, where it acquired captions and commentary and a life of its own that bore the usual relation to the event, which is to say a partial and overheated one. The bureau's public information office issued the statement that such offices issue, confirming an incident, confirming an investigation, confirming that an officer had been placed on administrative leave, and declining, in the formal language of decline, everything else. The court issued nothing. The United States District Court for the District of Oregon, asked by three networks and a wire service whether the judge wished to comment, replied through its executive that the court did not comment on matters concerning the personal safety of its judges and that the matter was in the hands of the appropriate authorities, a sentence that Simone had approved in draft and then sat looking at for a long time in her chambers, because it was accurate and because it was inadequate, and because the space between those two qualities was where she was now going to live for a while.
The investigators, meanwhile, did the unglamorous work that files are actually made of. They interviewed the sergeant, Voss, whose notebook was photographed page by page and whose account matched Keller's in every particular that two honest accounts of the same afternoon could be expected to match. They interviewed the dispatcher, who cried once, briefly, in the interview room, because she had sent the car and because the code she had entered, burglary in progress, had been the correct code for the information she had been given, and because she had begun, in the nights since, to hear the caller's calm voice in her sleep, saying the thing about the neighborhood. They retrieved the gate from the Ellis house and photographed it and tested its latch, and entered into the file the finding that the gate opened with one hand and a lift, as it had for fifty years, and that there was no damage to it of any kind, new or old, that could support the word forced. They walked the yard with a measuring wheel and a camera, in the rain that had finally come, and photographed the rose bed with the mud churned where a woman had knelt, and the walk where the hose had lain, and the porch boards where the pages had dried, though the pages themselves were by then in Simone's briefcase in an envelope marked in her hand, because she had declined, through her lawyer, to surrender her mother's estate papers to the file, and had provided instead a sworn inventory of them, item by item, with their condition described, which the file accepted, there being no argument available to it that a judge's dead mother's tax statements were evidence of anything except what had been done to them.