Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Simone never spoke about the garden in any statement, interview, or deposition. It was not evidence. It was hers. When Rebecca, preparing her for the civil deposition that the other side would one day take, asked her the standard question -- what she wanted, at the end of all of it, that she did not already have -- Simone considered the question with the care she gave to all questions that were really about remedy, and she said that she wanted the record to be complete and public, and she wanted the stamp retired, and she wanted, if the court of her own life had jurisdiction over such things, one more June in which the worst thing that happened in that yard was weather. Rebecca wrote down the first two. The third she left off the pad, out of a lawyer's instinct for what a record can hold, and then, driving home, she thought about it for the whole length of the river road, and when Simone's deposition was finally taken, months later, and the defense's lawyer asked his version of the same question, Simone gave the first two answers in her level voice, and the third she kept, the way she had kept her hands still in the mud: as the part of the truth that did not belong to the proceeding.

The civil case proceeded the way civil cases proceed, which is to say at the pace of paper accumulating in weather of its own. The city answered the complaint in September, in a document that admitted the encounter and denied the characterizations, admitted the leave and denied the liability, and asserted, in the numbered paragraphs of its kind, that the officer had acted on a good-faith report of a crime in progress and that the municipality's policies were constitutional in design and in application. Rebecca read the answer at her desk and then read it aloud to Simone over the telephone, in the tone of a woman reading a menu in a restaurant she has eaten at before. Every denial was expected. Every admission was useful. The case would now go where such cases go: into discovery, where the documents would be produced under obligation and oath, and where the file the bureau had built behind its wall would be required, piece by piece, to walk out into the daylight and be numbered as exhibits in a proceeding that belonged to the public.

The productions came in waves, as productions do, each wave preceded by a dispute about scope that a magistrate judge -- for Simone's case had been assigned, by the random draw of a court not her own, to a judge from another district, sitting by designation, a man of legendary patience and no local entanglements -- resolved with the even-handed speed of a man who had read the newspapers and intended that his courtroom not become one. The dispatch log came first, complete, with its six calls and its five closures and its executor twice named. The camera event log came with a technician's declaration explaining the sustained press, the design of the button, the impossibility of accident, in the flat language of engineering. The 911 recording came with its certified transcript, and beside it, because Rebecca's requests had been drafted by a woman who understood adjacency, the transcript of Keller's camera audio, so that the two sentences lay in the production as they lay in the bureau's file: facing each other. The personnel file came redacted in the places the law allowed and legible in the places that mattered: the three complaints, the three memoranda, the one signature, three times. The training records came, and with them the document that Rebecca, when she called Simone that evening, described as the one she would have traded the rest of the production to keep: Whitmore's own signed acknowledgment, from his most recent annual recertification, eleven months before the afternoon in the yard, attesting that he had received, read, and understood the bureau's body-worn camera policy, including the section, quoted in the acknowledgment itself, that prohibited deactivation during any encounter with a member of the public and prescribed the sustained press as a safeguard against inadvertent interruption. He had signed it in the ordinary course, between the firearms form and the driving form, in the annual blizzard of a working officer's paperwork. It was, like everything else in the case, a small document. The case was made of small documents. That was its nature and its strength: no single page of it could be argued with, and there were four thousand pages.

News in the same category

Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

45 Part