Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The judgeship, when it came, came by the long formal road: the application that reads like a biography cross-examined, the committee, the bar's evaluations, the senators, the investigators who visited her neighbors and her old teachers and asked the questions that the government asks when it is deciding whether to trust a person with a piece of itself. An agent had sat in Edith Harmon's kitchen, in those years, and drunk Edith's tea, and asked whether the Ellis girl had ever been in trouble, and Edith had said, as she reported to Lorraine afterward with enormous satisfaction, that Simone Ellis had been in trouble exactly once, at age eleven, for organizing the street's children into a court to try the case of a stolen bicycle, and that the proceedings had taken two afternoons and the bicycle had been returned and the thief, a boy of nine, had been sentenced to apology and community service in the form of raking, and had served both. The agent had written something down. Lorraine, hearing the story, had said that she hoped they knew what they were getting. The Senate, in due course, confirmed what it was getting by a voice vote on a Thursday, and Simone had sat in her office at the defense firm with the phone in her hand and cried, briefly and in the controlled way that was becoming her signature, and then she had gone home to her mother's house and told the roses first, because her mother was at the grocery store and the roses were the senior residents.

The investiture had been held in the ceremonial courtroom, with the flags and the portrait and the whole court sitting en banc in the front rows like a row of black birds. Lorraine had worn the navy dress. She had sat in the second row, in the seat that protocol assigned to family, and she had held, throughout the ceremony, the expression of a woman at a wedding she entirely approved of, and when the oath was administered -- the hand raised, the words repeated after the chief judge, the constitutional language rolling out across the room like a road being laid -- she had cried without embarrassment, and afterward, at the reception in the court's library, she had been introduced to senators and chief judges and the whole apparatus of her daughter's new world, and had charmed it in the manner of a woman who has never in her life been impressed by a title, including, her daughter suspected, this one. She had told the Chief Judge that she had always known. It was not true, exactly. What was true was narrower and better: she had always known what her daughter was, which is a different knowledge, and she had arranged her whole motherhood around the project of not standing in its way. The roses that year had been cut for the reception tables, forty stems, from the bed in the front yard, and Lorraine had cut them herself the morning of the ceremony, in the early light, with the kitchen shears, standing in the bed in her housecoat among the thorns like a woman harvesting her own evidence.

Simone thought about the investiture in the weeks after the encounter, on the bench, in the robing room, in the corridor where the protective detail stood -- she thought about it because the video had raised, in the public mind and therefore in hers, the question of what the robe actually was. In the yard she had not had it. She had had a ruined suit and a wallet with a badge in it, and she had learned, in one minute and fifty-two seconds of water, the precise difference between the authority of the office and the authority of the person, which is a difference that judges are trained never to examine too closely, because the system's whole architecture depends on their being the same thing. The office had not been in the yard. The office had been across the river, in a building with flags. What had been in the yard was a woman on her knees in her mother's garden, keeping her hands still, and the keeping still had been hers, not the office's -- hers and her mother's and her father's and Mrs. Abernathy's, the whole accumulated capital of a life, spent in a rose bed in the rain of a garden hose. And the sentence she had spoken, the second one, the one about the cameras and the career -- she examined it in the nights, the way she examined her own rulings for error, and she found that she did not regret it and could not have unsaid it, because it had not been a threat and it had not been a boast. It had been a finding. She had looked at the record being made around her -- the porch, the fence, the driveway, the young officer's chest -- and she had read it aloud, the way she read findings into the record in her courtroom, so that the record would be clear. If there was a judicial act in the yard that day, she decided, in the private court of her own conscience, that was it: not the credentials, which were merely paper and gold, but the reading of the record, aloud, in a level voice, by the only person in the yard who had been trained to do it.

News in the same category

Officer Hosed a Federal Judge Down in Her Own Mother's Rose Bed in Front of Every Neighbor's Camera

45 Part