“No. But I wrote down everything I could remember immediately afterward.”
“Then we need to contact him again.”
“Not yet.”
“Why?”
“Because he knows we're interested. If we approach him before we understand the documents, we may give someone an opportunity to interfere with the investigation.”
Marcus leaned back.
“You really believe someone could be watching us?”
“I believe someone has already demonstrated an unusual interest in what we are doing.”
Elena opened her laptop and brought up the email that had mentioned her name six weeks earlier.
The message had been sent from an administrative account inside the police department. It had instructed a records employee to notify the chief's office before responding to any further requests associated with Elena's work.
Marcus read the message twice.
“That isn't normal.”
“No.”
“Can we identify who sent it?”
“We can try.”
Elena enlarged the email header. The sender's name had been removed from the copy they possessed, but a partial routing identifier remained.
She wrote it down.
Then she searched the public employee directory and found a name that matched the department's records administration division.
Lydia Shaw.
According to the directory, Shaw had worked for Fairmont for seventeen years. She was not a police officer. She did not investigate crimes, supervise patrols, or participate in arrests. Her responsibilities involved document retention, records requests, and the transfer of administrative files.
In other words, she was exactly the kind of employee who might know which records existed, where they were stored, and who had access to them.
Elena wrote Shaw's name beneath the others.
“Let's find out whether she still works there,” she said.
Marcus checked the department directory.
“She does. Records administration, second floor.”
“Good.”
“Are you going to call her?”
“Not yet. First, I want the original dispatch record from my stop and the complete file on Anthony Lewis.”
Marcus nodded.
“What if they refuse to provide them?”
“Then we document the refusal and use the appropriate legal process.”
Elena closed the laptop.
“Every step has to be defensible. If this becomes a serious misconduct investigation, we cannot afford to give anyone an excuse to dismiss the evidence because we handled it carelessly.”
At eight thirty, she submitted formal requests for the records associated with her detention and the Lewis incident. She requested preservation of all available video footage, dispatch communications, officer reports, supervisory reviews, and records showing any changes made to the original documentation.
She also requested the retention logs for the relevant files.
The final request was important.
If a document had been altered, deleted, or transferred, the retention logs might reveal when the change occurred and who had authorized it.
Elena sent the requests through the appropriate channels and saved the confirmation receipts.
Then she waited.
She did not have to wait long.
At nine twelve, her office phone rang.
“This is Elena Brooks.”
“Ms. Brooks, my name is Lydia Shaw. I work in records administration for the Fairmont Police Department.”
Elena straightened.
“Yes, Ms. Shaw. How can I help you?”
“I received your records requests this morning.”
“Thank you for confirming receipt.”
There was a pause.
“I wanted to speak with you before processing them.”
“Is there a problem with the requests?”
“Not exactly.”
“What does that mean?”
Shaw lowered her voice.
“It means some of the records you requested are not where they should be.”
Elena glanced at Marcus, who had stopped typing.
“Could you explain?”
“I can't discuss the contents over the phone.”
“Then perhaps we should arrange a formal meeting.”
“No.”
The answer came so quickly that Elena paused.
“Why not?”
“Because if I meet you officially, someone will ask why. And if someone asks why, I'll be expected to explain what I told you.”
“Ms. Shaw, I cannot promise you confidentiality beyond what the law permits. But I can explain your options and make sure you understand your rights before you decide whether to provide information.”
“I don't need a lecture about my rights.”
“I wasn't offering one.”
Shaw fell silent.
When she spoke again, her voice sounded tired.
“I'm sorry. I shouldn't have called.”
“Wait. You said the records aren't where they should be. Are you referring to the dispatch log from my detention?”
“I'm referring to more than that.”
“Are the original files missing?”
“I didn't say that.”
“Have they been altered?”
“I didn't say that either.”
Elena chose her next words carefully.
“Ms. Shaw, if you have information about missing or altered official records, you do not have to disclose it to me over the phone. But I encourage you not to destroy, change, or remove anything. If you are concerned about pressure from your supervisors, you may seek independent legal advice.”