She opened a new document and recorded the conversation as accurately as she could remember it. She noted the date, time, phone number, and every statement Cole had made.
Then she printed the archived index and placed it beside the duty roster.
The documents appeared to support one another, but neither was conclusive by itself.
She needed the original supplemental report.
She also needed to know why it had disappeared.
At nine fifteen that evening, Elena received another call.
This time, the number was blocked.
She answered without speaking.
A man's voice came through.
“Ms. Brooks, you need to stop contacting former officers.”
“Who is this?”
“That doesn't matter.”
“It matters if you're asking me to change the way I conduct a lawful investigation.”
“You don't understand what you're dealing with.”
“Then explain it.”
The man laughed without humor.
“You think the department is your biggest problem? You think Mercer is the person everyone is worried about?”
Elena stood slowly.
“What are you saying?”
“I'm saying you're asking questions about records that were sealed for a reason.”
“Were they sealed lawfully?”
“You should be more concerned about your own safety.”
“Is that a threat?”
“It's advice.”
“I have received enough advice today.”
The man lowered his voice.
“Anthony Lewis wasn't the first. Michael Porter wasn't the first. And if you keep digging, you'll discover that neither of them was the reason those records disappeared.”
Elena's grip tightened around the phone.
“Then what was the reason?”
The caller did not answer.
Instead, he said, “Ask Captain Bell what happened on the night of November seventeenth.”
“November seventeenth of which year?”
But the caller had already disconnected.
Elena slowly lowered the phone.
Marcus, standing near the doorway, looked at her.
“November seventeenth?”
“That's what he said.”
“Do we know what happened that night?”
“Not yet.”
Elena returned to her desk and searched the records she had collected. The date did not immediately correspond to the Porter arrest or the Lewis incident. It was nearly a year before Michael had been stopped.
She searched the public court database, local news archives, and the department's published annual reports.
At first, she found nothing.
Then she located a brief newspaper article buried in an online archive.
The headline read:
FAIRMONT OFFICER KILLED IN LATE-NIGHT INCIDENT; INVESTIGATION UNDERWAY.
The article was dated November eighteenth, four years earlier.
The officer's name was Jonathan Reed.
He had been thirty-four years old.
He had served with the Fairmont Police Department for nine years.
According to the article, Reed had died after responding to a reported disturbance near an abandoned warehouse on the industrial edge of the city. The department had described the incident as an accidental discharge during a chaotic confrontation.
The investigation had been closed several months later.
No criminal charges had been filed.
Elena read the article twice.
Then she searched Jonathan Reed's name alongside Daniel Mercer, Thomas Bell, and Raymond Holloway.
A second article appeared.
It reported that Reed's family had requested an independent review after receiving conflicting explanations about the circumstances of his death. The department had denied any wrongdoing and stated that the available evidence supported its conclusions.
The article included a photograph of Reed standing beside a police cruiser.
He looked younger than Elena expected, with a broad smile and a wedding ring visible on his left hand.
Beneath the photograph was a quote from his widow.
My husband believed the truth mattered, even when it was uncomfortable. I only want someone to tell me what happened to him.
Elena felt the room grow very quiet.
She printed the articles and placed them beside the other documents.
Then she searched the department's records index for the November seventeenth incident.
A case number appeared.
The file was listed as restricted.
The reason for the restriction was not provided.
Elena wrote down the case number.
She now had a new name, a new date, and a possible connection between the missing records and the death of a police officer.
She did not know whether the connection was real.
But she understood why someone might be desperate to keep her from discovering it.
Because if the incidents involving Mercer, Lewis, and Porter were connected to the death of Jonathan Reed, the investigation would no longer be about a series of questionable arrests.
It would become a question about what had happened inside the Fairmont Police Department on a night four years earlier—and whether the official explanation for a man's death had concealed a truth that powerful people had spent years trying to bury.
And somewhere in the middle of that unanswered question stood Captain Thomas Bell, a retired supervisor who had suddenly become afraid of the past.