Denise looked down at the papers.
“That's the first honest thing anyone has said to me about this case in years.”
She gathered the pages into a neat stack.
“Michael is working today. He repairs delivery trucks at a garage on the south side. I'll speak with him tonight.”
Elena thanked her.
Before she left, Denise walked her to the front door.
“Ms. Brooks?”
“Yes?”
“If you discover that the department lied, don't let them turn this into a story about one bad officer.”
Elena looked at her.
“What do you mean?”
Denise's eyes filled with tears, but her voice remained firm.
“People like Mercer don't become untouchable by themselves. Somebody has to ignore the complaints. Somebody has to lose the records. Somebody has to tell the family that nothing can be done. And somebody has to decide that the truth is less important than protecting the department.”
Elena thought of Chief Holloway's memorandum.
“I won't assume the answer before the evidence is examined,” she said. “But I won't ignore the possibility that the problem goes beyond one officer.”
Denise nodded.
“That's all I'm asking.”
As Elena drove away, she kept thinking about the second officer.
If Michael's account was accurate, another member of the department had witnessed at least part of the encounter. That officer might have been a potential witness, a participant, or someone who had tried to intervene and then withdrawn.
The official report did not identify anyone matching the description.
That absence was significant, but its meaning remained uncertain.
The officer could have been off duty. He could have belonged to another agency. Michael could have misremembered a detail. Or someone might have deliberately omitted him from the report.
Elena needed evidence that could distinguish between those possibilities.
She returned to her office and contacted Marcus.
“Have you received anything from Peter Wallace?”
“He sent the archived case index. There's a reference to a supplemental report that isn't included in the file.”
“Who wrote it?”
“The index doesn't say. It just lists the document as an attachment.”
“Can you ask him to check the original archive?”
“I already did. He's searching for it.”
Elena told him about Denise's handwritten account and the second officer.
Marcus listened carefully.
“If the second officer is real, the department should have a roster showing who was working that shift.”
“Exactly.”
“Can we request it?”
“Yes. We can request the duty roster, vehicle assignments, and any records showing officers dispatched to the location. We should also ask whether another agency was operating nearby.”
Marcus began making a list.
“What about the pharmacy?”
“We need to determine whether its camera system retained footage for the relevant period. The incident happened four years ago, so the original recording may be gone. But maintenance records or correspondence about the request might still exist.”
He nodded.
“And if they don't?”
“Then we document that.”
Elena filed the additional requests that afternoon.
Two hours later, an email arrived from an address she did not recognize.
There was no greeting and no signature.
The message contained a single attachment: a scanned copy of an internal duty roster dated four years earlier.
Elena opened the file.
The document listed twelve officers assigned to the relevant patrol area on the night Michael Porter had been arrested. Mercer was listed near the top. Captain Bell was listed as the supervising officer.
Halfway down the page was a name Elena had never seen before.
Officer Adrian Cole.
Beside his name was a notation indicating that he had been assigned to a secondary patrol unit but had been temporarily reassigned to assist another officer.
The time of the reassignment matched the period during which Michael claimed the second officer had appeared.
Elena leaned closer to the screen.
She checked the spelling, the badge number, and the unit designation.
Then she searched the public records available to her.
Adrian Cole had left the Fairmont Police Department three years earlier. His departure had been described as a voluntary resignation. There were no public disciplinary findings associated with his name.
Elena printed the roster.
For several minutes, she studied the document.
If the roster was authentic, Cole could be the second officer Michael remembered.
But why had his involvement been omitted from the report?
And why had someone sent the roster anonymously, without explaining where it came from?
Elena checked the email headers and saved the original message. She did not reply.
Instead, she called Marcus.
“I think we have a name.”
He arrived at her office within fifteen minutes.
Elena showed him the roster.