The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Second copy delivered to R.

Below it was a date that seemed to read November sixteenth, though the final digit was blurred.

Elena felt her pulse quicken.

“November sixteenth,” she said. “The day before Reed died.”

Marcus bent closer.

“That's what it appears to say. The examiner will need to assess the image quality before we rely on the date.”

Bell rubbed his forehead.

“I don't remember seeing that date before.”

“Do you recognize the handwriting?” Elena asked.

“No.”

“Could it be yours?”

“I don't believe so.”

“Could it be Reed's?”

“I can't tell.”

Marcus looked up.

“Captain, do you remember receiving this report before or after November seventeenth?”

Bell considered the question.

“I remember Reed discussing the discrepancy before his death. I remember having a copy afterward. I cannot honestly tell you whether this particular copy came into my possession before or after the incident.”

“That's important,” Marcus said. “Please don't guess.”

“I won't.”

The examiner arrived shortly afterward. Her name was Dr. Helen Morris, and she had spent more than twenty years examining questioned documents and photocopied records. She explained that her role was not to determine whether the department had committed misconduct. Her job was to evaluate the material in front of her and identify what could and could not be concluded from it.

She photographed every page in its original position. Then she examined the report under magnification and compared its layout with a publicly available blank version of the department's form.

“The formatting is broadly consistent with the form used during the relevant period,” she said. “That doesn't establish that this particular document was produced by the department. A photocopy can preserve the appearance of an original without preserving the information needed to authenticate it.”

“What can you tell us about the handwritten notation?” Marcus asked.

“I can document its visible characteristics. I may be able to compare it with known handwriting samples if you provide authenticated examples. But handwriting comparison has limits, especially when we're examining a low-quality photocopy rather than the original writing.”

“Can you tell whether the date was written before or after the page was copied?”

“No. Not from this image.”

“Can you tell whether the missing page was removed deliberately?”

“No. The damage is consistent with tearing, but I can't determine when or why it occurred.”

Elena appreciated the examiner's restraint. Every answer was carefully bounded by what the evidence could support.

Dr. Morris completed the photographs and prepared a preliminary inventory. The document was returned to Bell, who placed it in a protective sleeve and agreed to keep it secure until further steps could be arranged.

Before leaving, he turned toward Elena.

“I want you to know something. When Reed first spoke to me about the Porter report, I thought it was a minor administrative problem. I assumed that if a report had been filed incorrectly, someone could correct it. I didn't imagine that the original would become difficult to locate.”

“Did you ask anyone to correct it?”

“I may have asked the records office to verify the dates. I don't remember making a formal request.”

“Could that request be documented?”

“If it was entered into the system.”

“And if it wasn't?”

“Then my memory may be the only evidence that I asked.”

Elena nodded.

“Your memory is evidence of what you remember. It isn't proof that the request was entered or that anyone acted on it.”

Bell gave a faint, weary smile.

“You really do refuse to make things easy.”

“I refuse to make them easier than they are.”

He stood, thanked Marcus, and left.

Once the door closed, Marcus reviewed the examiner's preliminary notes.

“We now have a document that may contain information missing from the official version,” he said. “But we still don't know whether it's authentic, whether the notation is contemporaneous, or who received the second copy.”

“We also have a possible date immediately before Reed's death.”

“Possibly. That's the most significant detail, but also the one most vulnerable to misinterpretation.”

Elena agreed.

“If we can establish who had access to the file on November sixteenth, we may be able to identify the recipient.”

“Or we may discover that the date refers to something unrelated.”

“Either way, we need the access records.”

Marcus opened the department's preservation acknowledgment.

“Then let's make the next request specific. We should ask for the original Porter case index, every available version of the supplemental report, the history of changes to the index, and the record of any transfer or duplication made between November fifteenth and November twentieth.”

News in the same category

The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

45 Part