After the call, Elena began drafting the request. She included the date of Reed's death, the documented closure period, the existence of a later administrative entry, and the discrepancy between the public report and the references to additional evidence. She requested preservation of the original electronic records, associated audit trails, and any available backups or migration logs.
She also asked that the department identify any records that no longer existed, along with the date and authority under which they had been disposed of or transferred.
It was a modest request on paper. It did not accuse the chief, Mercer, Bell, or anyone else of criminal conduct. But it would require someone to examine the history of the file rather than relying on the version currently visible in the system.
Before sending it, Elena reread every sentence. She removed an adjective that implied intentional concealment. She changed “altered report” to “report with an unexplained discrepancy.” She replaced “missing evidence” with “referenced material not included in the available copy.”
Then she sent the request.
At 11:42 a.m., the confirmation arrived.
At 12:06 p.m., an unfamiliar number called her office.
Elena answered.
“Attorney Brooks.”
A man's voice came through the line.
“You need to stop requesting records about November seventeenth.”
“Who is this?”
“That doesn't matter.”
“It matters to me.”
“You've already been warned.”
“I receive a great deal of advice from people who don't identify themselves.”
“This isn't advice.”
“Then is it a threat?”
“No. It's an opportunity to walk away before you destroy your career over a story you don't understand.”
Elena opened a blank document and began recording the time and substance of the call.
“Which part of the story don't I understand?”
“The part where you think every inconsistency means corruption.”
“I haven't made that claim.”
“You're asking for records that were restricted for a reason.”
“Then the department can identify the legal basis for withholding them.”
“You think a judge will save you?”
“I think the law provides procedures for resolving disputes over records.”
The caller laughed without humor.
“You really believe procedure protects you.”
“No,” Elena said. “I believe it creates a record of who chose to follow it and who chose not to.”
The man went quiet.
Then he said, “Ask Bell what he did with the second copy.”
Elena's hand froze over the keyboard.
“What second copy?”
But the caller had already disconnected.
She sat motionless, listening to the dead line.
The phrase could mean almost anything. Another copy of Reed's note. A duplicate report. A second version of the evidence index. It might be a deliberate attempt to confuse her, or it might be information that only someone familiar with the investigation could know.
She did not call Bell immediately.
Instead, she saved the call notes, documented the number, and forwarded the information to Marcus. Then she reviewed everything she had learned that morning and added one question to her list:
What second copy, and who knew it existed?
For the first time, Elena understood that the investigation was no longer simply about recovering documents. It was about establishing which version of events had been preserved, which version had been used to justify official decisions, and whether anyone had quietly substituted one for the other.
Somewhere in Fairmont, someone knew the answer.
And that person had just made it clear that Elena was getting close enough to frighten them.
Elena did not sleep well that night.
The anonymous caller's final words kept returning to her mind. Ask Bell what he did with the second copy.
The phrase was too specific to dismiss, yet too vague to trust. It might have been a genuine clue, a calculated attempt to make her distrust Bell, or a way to push her toward an assumption that would later undermine the entire investigation. Whoever had called knew that she had met the retired captain, or at least knew that Bell remained connected to the questions surrounding Jonathan Reed's death.
Elena had learned long ago that fear could make people careless. It could also make them see patterns where none existed. She would allow neither possibility to dictate her next move.
At seven the following morning, she arrived at her office and found a message from Marcus Hill waiting in her inbox.
I reviewed the preservation request. The language is solid. Before we send a second request or make any public statement, I recommend confirming what Bell meant by the copy he gave you. Also, the number from yesterday's call appears to be registered through a prepaid service. No useful subscriber information.