The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Elena stared at the screen for several seconds before lowering the phone.

For the first time since she began investigating the department, she had something more substantial than a warning or an anonymous document. Bell had acknowledged that Reed had documented something, that an original report was missing or inaccessible, and that the night of his death involved details the public account had not captured.

It was not proof of misconduct. It was not proof that Mercer had been involved. But it was enough to justify a careful, independent inquiry.

She opened a new document and recorded the conversation while the details were fresh. She separated Bell's direct statements from her own interpretations, marking every uncertainty. She did not write that Mercer had been present. She wrote that Bell recalled seeing Mercer's name on a document afterward but could not identify the document or confirm the circumstances.

Precision mattered. If the investigation ever reached court, an exaggerated claim could destroy the credibility of a legitimate one.

At ten minutes past eight, Elena saved the notes in two secure locations and sent a brief message to her trusted colleague, attorney Marcus Hill.

I may have located a witness connected to the Reed investigation. I'm meeting him tomorrow morning. If I don't contact you by noon, call me. Don't investigate the matter independently yet. I'll explain when we speak.

Marcus responded almost immediately.

Understood. Do you want me there?

Not yet. I need to hear what he says before we decide what comes next.

She put the phone away and returned to the documents.

The next two hours produced more questions than answers.

The public report listed the responding officers, but the sequence of arrivals was vague. The supplemental page referenced an evidence inventory without identifying every item collected. A paragraph described a weapon discharged during a struggle, yet the public summary did not explain who had been holding the weapon at the moment it fired. The department's statement said the incident had been reconstructed from witness accounts, but the witness list was not included.

Most troubling was the closure date. The investigation had supposedly been completed months after Reed's death, yet a later administrative entry referred to a review conducted after the file was marked closed. The entry contained no explanation of what had been reviewed or why.

Elena made a list of the questions she could pursue lawfully: the original evidence inventory, the chain-of-custody log, the complete list of responding officers, the dates of every administrative review, and any records showing when the file's status changed.

She would not assume that missing records had been deliberately destroyed. Records could be misfiled, transferred, misclassified, or withheld under legitimate restrictions. But each explanation needed to be documented, not merely asserted.

At eleven, she called Lydia Shaw, the records administrator who had warned her about the missing body-camera index in the Lewis case.

Lydia answered in a whisper.

“You shouldn't call me at work.”

“I'll keep this brief. Do you know the Reed case?”

“I know the number.”

“Can you tell me whether the original evidence inventory still exists?”

“I can't discuss a restricted investigation.”

“I'm not asking you to disclose its contents. I'm asking whether the inventory is listed in the records system.”

“I shouldn't be answering this.”

“Then don't answer anything you're not authorized to answer. But if you know of a discrepancy, you can preserve the record of that discrepancy through the proper process.”

Lydia was silent for a moment.

“Look at the revision history,” she said finally.

“Of which document?”

“The case index. Not the public report. The index.”

“Does the index show a revision?”

“It shows that the file was updated after closure.”

“By whom?”

“I can't tell you that.”

“Does it show what changed?”

“Not in the version you requested.”

Elena wrote the details down.

“Is there a separate audit log?”

“There should be.”

“Should be?”

“Some of the older systems were migrated. The audit logs weren't always transferred with the files.”

“Do you know whether this one was transferred?”

“No.”

“Can the department determine that?”

“Yes, if someone asks the right person.”

“Who is the right person?”

Lydia drew a shaky breath.

“Information technology. Records management. Internal affairs. It depends on what they're willing to look at.”

“Thank you.”

“Don't thank me.” Lydia's voice became more urgent. “And don't put my name in a filing unless you have to.”

“I won't identify you as a source without discussing it with you first.”

“That's not what I meant. I mean don't assume that keeping my name out of a document will keep me safe.”

News in the same category

The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

45 Part