The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“I don't want to tell you something that may turn out to be incomplete. A retired captain has told me that Jonathan was reviewing a discrepancy in an arrest report before he died. The report concerned Michael Porter, a young man who was arrested by Officer Daniel Mercer several years ago. I have not seen the original document, and I cannot yet establish whether it had anything to do with Jonathan's death.”

Patricia breathed in sharply.

“Jonathan mentioned an arrest to me.”

“What did he say?”

“He came home one night and told me that a young man had been treated unfairly. He said the department had accepted an officer's version of events without checking the records. I asked him whether he was going to do anything about it, and he said he was trying to establish what had happened before he accused anyone.”

“Did he name Michael Porter?”

“No. I don't remember him mentioning a name. He said the problem wasn't necessarily one officer. He said the problem was that everyone trusted the report because it had been signed by someone wearing a uniform.”

Elena wrote down the statement, making clear that it was Patricia's recollection and not an independently verified quotation.

“Did Jonathan say he had obtained a copy of the report?”

“No. But he started bringing home a small notebook. He wrote things in it and kept it in a drawer beside his desk. After he died, I couldn't find it.”

“Did you tell investigators about the notebook?”

“Yes. They asked whether Jonathan had been under stress or had been involved in any disputes at work. I told them he had been worried about something in the department. They asked if I could identify the subject. I couldn't, so they moved on.”

“Did anyone search his desk?”

“His supervisor came to our house two days after the funeral. He said he wanted to collect department property. He took Jonathan's service badge, a radio charger, and some paperwork. I asked whether he needed to take the notebook too. He said he hadn't seen one.”

“Did you see him remove any notebook?”

“No. I didn't know where it was at the time. I only remembered it later, when I was looking for something else.”

Elena wrote another note.

“Mrs. Reed, I want to be careful here. The fact that a notebook is missing doesn't establish that anyone took it. It may have been misplaced, collected with other papers, or moved somewhere else. But your recollection could help establish what records existed before the investigation.”

“I understand.”

“Would you be willing to meet with me and an independent attorney? We can document your recollections and discuss how to preserve the envelope and marked report.”

“I would. But I need you to understand something first.”

“Please tell me.”

“I don't want you to use Jonathan's death as a way to prove something about Daniel Mercer. I have heard people say that Mercer is a bully. I have heard people say he should never have been a police officer. Maybe they are right. I don't know everything he did.”

She paused.

“My husband is not a weapon you can point at someone you already suspect.”

Elena felt the force of the rebuke and accepted it.

“You're right. I won't treat him that way.”

“I want to know why the investigation changed its account of what happened. I want to know why I was given different explanations. I want to know whether the department preserved the evidence it claimed to review. If the answer is that Jonathan died in an accident, then I want the evidence to support that answer. If the answer is something else, I want that established too.”

“That is exactly the standard I'm trying to apply.”

“Then I'll meet you.”

They agreed to meet at Patricia's lawyer's office two days later. Elena recorded the appointment in her calendar and sent Marcus a message explaining that Jonathan's widow had contacted her independently. She did not send him Patricia's private recollections without permission.

After the call, Elena sat quietly for a moment.

The investigation was widening, but the widening did not necessarily mean the pieces belonged together. The Porter report might be relevant to Reed's work without being relevant to his death. The conflicting accounts of the warehouse incident might reflect poor documentation rather than deliberate deception. The anonymous messages might come from someone seeking justice, someone protecting themselves, or someone hoping to create a false narrative.

Elena needed evidence that could survive all three possibilities.

At lunchtime, she walked to a nearby café and ordered a sandwich. She had taken only a few bites when her phone vibrated.

News in the same category

The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

45 Part