The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

Chapter 43

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Outside the building, Marcus called Elena.

“There's another development,” he said.

“What is it?”

“The department has responded to the dispatch-record request.”

Elena stopped beside her car.

“What did they say?”

“They've located a record associated with the number. But they say access is restricted because the event was incorporated into a separate internal review.”

“Which review?”

“They haven't identified it.”

“Did they confirm the date?”

“Yes. The record was created on November fourteenth, three days before Reed died.”

Elena opened her notebook.

“Does it identify the incident?”

“Not in the response. They've provided a partial index entry, and the incident location has been redacted.”

“Did they give a reason for the redaction?”

“They cite the restricted status of the underlying review. We can challenge that, but first we need the complete index history.”

“Was the record modified?”

“That's where it gets interesting. The index lists an amendment on November sixteenth, followed by another change after the investigation was closed.”

Elena stared at the pavement.

“Do we know what changed?”

“No. The department says the available index doesn't preserve the content of earlier versions.”

“Does it identify who made the changes?”

“Not in the copy they provided.”

“Then we need the audit logs.”

“I've already drafted the follow-up.”

Elena leaned against the car.

Three dates now appeared across different records: November fourteenth, when the dispatch event was created; November sixteenth, when the index was amended; and November seventeenth, when Jonathan Reed died.

The chronology was becoming harder to dismiss as a coincidence, but it still did not prove that the dispatch event concerned Reed, Porter, or Mercer. A police department handled hundreds of incidents. An index amendment could be routine. The question was whether the underlying record would show why the change occurred.

“Send the follow-up,” Elena said. “Ask them to preserve the earlier index versions, the access logs, and any records showing who requested or approved the amendment.”

“Already done.”

“And don't send Patricia's documents yet. We need to establish what the dispatch number represents before we expose her private papers to the department.”

“Agreed.”

They ended the call.

Elena sat in her car without starting the engine. The department had confirmed that a record existed, but the response was carefully limited. It did not say the record had been deleted. It did not say the amendment was improper. It did not explain why the event had been incorporated into an internal review.

She began to write a timeline on the back of her notebook.

November 14: Dispatch event created.

November 15: Jonathan's handwritten note indicates a discrepancy was identified.

November 16: Dispatch index amended; Jonathan's notes refer to a second copy request.

November 17: Jonathan Reed dies after responding to an incident near the warehouse.

Later: The case index is amended again after the death investigation is closed.

The sequence was compelling, but she marked each entry with its source and reliability. The dispatch dates came from the department's partial index. The dates in Jonathan's notes came from documents whose authenticity still needed to be assessed. The date of Reed's death came from the public report.

She did not draw a line connecting them.

Not yet.

That afternoon, Marcus received another message from the department's records division. It stated that the amendment to the dispatch index had been approved by a supervisor, but the supervisor's name was not included in the copy released to them.

The approval field had not been redacted under a specific statutory exemption. Instead, the department said the field was unavailable in the current export.

Marcus called Elena immediately.

“That's not a denial,” he said. “It's a claim about the system's limitations. We need to know whether the information exists elsewhere.”

“Could the original database still contain it?”

“It could. So could an audit log or a backup. But we can't assume the information survived the migration.”

“Can we ask the department's technology unit to certify that no earlier version exists?”

“Yes. We should ask them to identify the systems searched, the dates covered by the search, and the person who conducted it.”

Elena considered the wording.

“If they say the information is unavailable, I want to know whether they mean it never existed, was not transferred, or was deleted later. Those are three different explanations.”

“Exactly.”

They prepared another request.

This time, the department did not respond with a routine acknowledgment.

At 4:51 p.m., Chief Raymond Holloway called Elena directly.

“Attorney Brooks,” he said, his voice measured and formal. “I understand you've submitted several requests concerning a historical dispatch event and the Reed investigation.”

News in the same category

The courtroom fell silent the moment Officer Daniel Mercer stepped away from the witness stand and pointed an accusing finger at the woman sitting before him.

45 Part