Only after those questions were answered could she begin to determine whether the discrepancy was an ordinary administrative error, a deliberate alteration, or something more complicated.
At ten thirty, she received a formal response from the Fairmont Police Department.
The letter was short, polite, and carefully worded. The department acknowledged receipt of her preservation request and stated that responsive records would be retained in accordance with applicable policy. It did not confirm whether the requested audit logs existed. It did not address the reported revision after the case had been closed. It did not identify any official who had reviewed the index.
At the bottom of the letter was the name of the person responsible for the response.
Chief Raymond Holloway.
Elena read it twice.
The chief had chosen to respond personally to a request that could have been handled by the records division. That did not prove he was involved in any wrongdoing. He might have considered the matter important enough to oversee himself. He might have wanted to prevent an administrative mistake. Or he might have wanted to know exactly which records Elena was seeking.
Whatever the reason, the request had reached the highest level of the department.
She forwarded the letter to Marcus.
His response arrived within minutes.
The preservation acknowledgment is useful, but it isn't a substantive answer. We should request the audit history separately and ask them to identify the custodian responsible for maintaining it. If the records are restricted, they should state the specific basis for withholding them.
Elena agreed and began drafting the follow-up.
Before she could finish, her office phone rang.
“Attorney Brooks.”
A woman spoke in a controlled, professional voice.
“My name is Patricia Reed. I was told you were asking questions about my husband.”
Elena felt her shoulders tighten.
Jonathan Reed's widow.
“Mrs. Reed, thank you for calling. I am investigating a number of questions concerning police records and past complaints. I have not made any conclusions about your husband's death.”
“I know. I read the letter you sent to the department.”
Elena frowned.
“I haven't sent a letter to you.”
“No, you sent a request to the police department. Someone forwarded a copy to me.”
“Who?”
“I don't know. It came in an envelope with no return address.”
“Did the envelope contain anything else?”
“A photocopy of the public report about Jonathan's death. There was a sentence marked in red.”
“What sentence?”
“‘The incident was reconstructed from witness accounts and available physical evidence.’ Underneath it, someone had written, ‘Not all accounts were included.’”
Elena closed her eyes briefly.
“Mrs. Reed, do you still have the envelope and the marked report?”
“Yes.”
“Please keep them exactly as they arrived. Don't write on them or send them to anyone until you've had advice about preserving them.”
“That's what I thought you would say.”
“May I ask why you called me?”
“Because I have spent years asking the department what happened to my husband, and every person I spoke to gave me a different version of the same story. They told me he had responded to a disturbance. They told me there was a confrontation. They told me his weapon discharged during the struggle. They told me the investigation had been thorough.”
Her voice wavered, but she continued.
“Then I asked why one officer said Jonathan arrived after the confrontation had begun, while another said he was already at the warehouse when the first unit got there. I asked why the report mentioned three officers in one place and four in another. I asked why I was never given a complete list of witnesses.”
“What did they tell you?”
“They said the differences were minor. They said people remembered stressful events differently. They said I was grieving and that grief made it difficult to accept what had happened.”
Elena felt anger rising, but she kept her voice calm.
“Did anyone provide you with the underlying statements?”
“No. They said I wasn't entitled to every document in a restricted investigation. I hired a lawyer, and we submitted requests. Some records were withheld. Others were summarized. We were told that the available evidence supported the department's conclusion.”
“Did your lawyer ever see the complete file?”
“He said he couldn't obtain it.”
“Did you know Jonathan had been concerned about Michael Porter's arrest?”
Patricia was silent.
“No,” she said at last. “What arrest?”
Elena realized she had moved too quickly.