The Little Girl in the Blue Dress Who Knocked the Teacup Out of Her Father's Hand and Pointed at His Wife

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

It was the question he had not meant to ask. The others had been evidence, chronology, law; this one came up out of the part of him that had stood on courthouse steps in March genuinely happy, with the spring wind in his face, believing his life had been returned to him by a merciful universe. He heard how young it sounded. He hated that it sounded young. He let it stand anyway, because his daughter was behind him learning, from his back if not his words, what a person did with the truth in this house from now on: you said it plainly, and you did not take it back for pride.

Audrey considered him. For an instant — he would think about it in the nights to come, though he would never say so — something that might have been the ghost of an answer crossed her face, some complication, some nearly-human snag in the inventory. Then it cleared, and she gave him the truth, and he understood that she gave it not from any mercy but because the truth, at last, was the sharpest available instrument and she had always liked her instruments sharp.

"You were supposed to be grateful," she said. "That is the whole of what was real, from my side of the table. I came into a house of grief and I warmed it. I learned her name" — the faintest nod toward the whole of Claire's house around them — "and her recipes and her child's bedtime, and I performed a resurrection for you, nightly, in a burgundy dress, and you were supposed to be grateful, and you were. Gratitude is the finest blindfold ever made. A grateful man does not ask why his wife insists on carrying the teapot herself. A grateful man does not ask why she keeps a bottle behind the flour tin. A grateful man drinks." She looked, briefly, down at the table, at the empty place where his cup had stood, and a flicker of genuine professional irritation crossed her face, there and gone. "Men like you always are," she said. "Grateful. It is the one reliable thing about men like you. I have built —" She checked herself, on some threshold even now; some names, some other husband in Ohio, stayed behind her teeth. "It has never failed before. It failed today because a six-year-old girl got up early to fetch a glass of water. Do you understand that? Your whole life was saved because a child was thirsty. There is no plan that survives that. There is no one who can be expected to plan for *that*."

"You threatened her," Christopher said. "In the kitchen. Boarding school. You stood over my six-year-old daughter, who had watched you dose her father's tea, and you told her that if she spoke she would be sent away. That is the part—" His voice broke its level at last, and he let it, he let her hear it break, because the breaking was also evidence. "Of everything you have done in my house, Audrey, that is the part I will describe to them first. Not the bottle. The threat. You looked at a child whose mother is dead and you used the exact shape of her worst fear — being sent away from me — as a lock for her mouth. And it nearly worked. It nearly worked all morning. She only ran when the cup was already at my lips."

"And if she hadn't?" Audrey said, almost gently. "You would have drunk it. Thanking me." She lifted one shoulder. "That is what I am telling you, Christopher. I am the only person in this room who has ever told you the truth about yourself. I did not make you blind. I found you blind, sitting in the dark by choice, with a child knocking on the inside of the door. I simply —" For the first time she searched for a word, and the one she chose was, in its way, the most terrible of the morning. "Decorated."

He looked at her for a long moment, his wife, standing in his first wife's dining room in her burgundy dress, with her confession arranged around her like the last and best of her performances, and he felt the interview close inside him like a book. There was nothing further in her. There had perhaps never been anything further in her, and the recognition came not as pain but as a kind of terrible rest: he could stop, now, trying to find the woman he had married somewhere inside the woman in front of him. She was not in there. She had never been in there. The woman he had married had been a dress and a voice and a hand over his on a table, and she had just told him so herself, as a point of professional pride.

"Sit down, Audrey," he said, quietly.

Her eyes moved — he saw it happen, the inventory becoming a survey — past him, to the doorway where Hazel hid, and beyond it to the hall, the front of the house, the drive. It was not the look of a woman preparing to run so much as the look of a woman for whom running was a category, a permanent line item, being weighed against the others by reflex. Everything in her was exits. It had probably been exits since she was younger than Hazel was now, and for one half-second he felt the vertigo of the whole of her: a life spent entirely in doorways, evaluating them.

News in the same category

The Little Girl in the Blue Dress Who Knocked the Teacup Out of Her Father's Hand and Pointed at His Wife

45 Part