told the road would punish hurry. He stood on the porch with a cup of coffee
gone cold in his hand and watched it come, and he knew before it stopped
what kind of errand it was. Debt collectors drove faster. Drummers drove
lighter cars. This one had the weight of paper in it.
Jude came out of the barn with a wrench in his hand and stood beside him.
Neither of them spoke. The car pulled into the yard and killed its engine and
sat ticking in the heat, and the driver got out and stood a moment looking at
the house the way a man looks at a photograph he has been shown once and
means to remember. He was not young. His suit was summer-weight and his
hat was clean, and he carried a briefcase of the good brown leather that does
not crack in this country because it is never left in the sun. He took off his hat
before he reached the porch steps, which Wade noted, the way he had once
noted the hands of men coming onto a rig floor โ what a man does with his
hat tells you whether he has come to fight or to file.
"Mr. Donnelly," he said. "Mr. Wade Donnelly, I believe. My name is Harlan
36
Beck. I'm an attorney, out of Abilene, and I represent Mr. Clayton
Bannister." He looked past Wade to Jude. "And you'd be Mr. Jude Donnelly.
I've come on a matter of business that concerns the ranch, and I'd be obliged
if we could sit down. I've driven a long way in a hot car, and I'd as soon not
do this standing in a yard."
Rosa was at the screen door before either of her sons could answer. She had
heard the car, and she had put on her good apron over her housedress, which
was her way of receiving anything official. "Then you'll come in and sit," she
said. "There's coffee. Whatever you've brought, Mr. Beck, it will keep ten
minutes while you drink a cup like a Christian."
He almost smiled at that. "Ma'am, I'd be grateful."
They sat in the front room, where the curtains were drawn against the west
sun and the air smelled of lamp oil and the faint green ghost of the rain that
never came. Beck set the briefcase across his knees and did not open it until
the coffee had been poured and praised. He had the manners of a man who
had served process in ranch houses for thirty years and had learned that the
paper went down easier after the courtesies, and Wade understood that this
was not kindness exactly, but it was not cruelty either. It was a profession.
"You'll want to know why I'm here and not a sheriff's deputy," Beck said at
last. "There's no deputy because there's no wrongdoing alleged. This is a civil
matter. A question of title." He opened the briefcase and took out a sheaf of
papers, and laid the top one on the table between the coffee cups with the
care of a man setting down something that might go off. "Mr. Bannister has
purchased certain interests from the estate of a Mr. Augustus Donnelly,
deceased, late of Fort Worth โ a cousin of your father's, I believe, snapped
the ranch's younger branch." He said it without any satisfaction. "Among the
papers in that estate was a deed. It's dated the fourteenth of March, 1911. The
37
grantor is Mr. Josiah Donnelly โ your great-uncle, as I make the family out.
By that instrument, Mr. Josiah Donnelly conveyed, and I quote the language
because the language is the whole of it, 'the subterranean stream and all
waters beneath' a tract described by metes and bounds in the deed. The
described tract takes in the head of the canyon your family calls the Devil's
Kitchen, and a section to the north of it."
Jude had set his cup down. "Josiah Donnelly never owned a spoonful of this
ranch. He was a drunk in El Paso. My grandfather paid his rail fare out of
this county twice."
"Your grandfather's opinion of him is recorded nowhere in the deed, Mr.
Donnelly," Beck said mildly. "The deed is recorded. Book forty-one, page
two-twelve, Caldera County. It has been of record for forty-four years. The
severance it makes is a common one in this state โ the mineral estate is
severed from the surface every day of the week, and a water estate is severed
the same way, by the same pen. Mr. Bannister now holds that water estate.
He holds it entire."
Rosa had not touched her coffee. She was looking at the paper on the table
without reaching for it, the way she looked at a snake in the yard โ not
afraid, but doing the arithmetic of it. "And what does Mr. Bannister propose
to do with his โ estate," she said.
"What he proposes, ma'am, is in the petition, of which this is your copy."
Beck slid a second, thicker document across. "Mr. Bannister has filed in the
district court of Caldera County an action to quiet title to the waters
described, and to enjoin the further diversion of those waters โ that is the
petition's word, diversion โ for purposes not appurtenant to the tract. The
petition sets out that the spring at the head of the Devil's Kitchen rises from
the severed stream; that the Donnelly family has for some years permitted the
38
taking of that water by the households of Loma Seca; and that such taking is,