the old men, and I carried water down to the crossing myself for women
whose buckets were too heavy for the path."
She named the families anyway, in the course of it β not as accusation and
not as sentiment, but as census, the way a woman reads a church roll: the
Herreras, who had come from the south valley with everything they owned in
a wagon and had stayed forty years and raised citizens; the Merritt widow,
who buried three husbands out of that water, as Rosa said, and outlived the
county's pity; families gone to California in the forties whose names were
still said at the crossing when their kin came back to visit graves. The court
reporter got it all down. Wade watched the machine eat the years and thought
that this was the part of the case no deed could be written against, because it
95
was not an argument. It was a population.
"And in all that time," the lawyer said, "did any person β any owner, any
agent of an estate β ever come to the spring and assert a right to the water
under it, or ask your family's permission to be refused or granted?"
"No. Not in 1917, not in the thirties, not in the war, not in this drought. Men
came with barrels. No man ever came with paper. This spring" β and she
nodded, once, toward the plaintiff's table, not rudely, the way you indicate
weather coming over a ridge β "is the first paper that spring has ever seen."
Beck rose to cross-examine, and Wade respected him again for the way he
approached his mother: no tricks, no raised voice, a lawyer who knew the
room would forgive him his case but not his manners. "Mrs. Donnelly, your
family's generosity is not on trial here, and I won't pretend otherwise. Let me
ask about the deed. You knew the grantor β the man who executed the
instrument in 1911. He was your husband's uncle."
"He was." The lawyer from Abilene set a framed photograph on the rail in
front of her, at Beck's request, produced from the estate papers. "That's him.
That's Henry's uncle." She looked at the photograph the way a woman looks
at a snake she has already killed once and is pleased to find still dead. "He
was the handsomest man in three counties and the charmingest, and
charming was his trade the way blacksmithing is another man's. He could sell
a widow a bridge she was standing on. He was a bankrupt when he died and
a bankrupt most of the years between, and everybody knew it except the men
he was selling to, and he timed it so they'd find out from each other."
"And the instrument itself, Mrs. Donnelly β do you say he had no right to
convey what it describes?"
"I say what I know," Rosa said. "I know he sold the waters under the mesa in
96
1911, because the paper is in this room. And I know" β and here her voice
did not rise, but it changed, the way a creek changes at the place it goes over
rock β "that in 1913 he sold the same subterranean stream, the same words,
the same waters under the same ground, to a cattleman from the Pecos
country and to a land company out of El Paso, for money, both of them, and
when the two of them came to compare their papers the county ran him out
of it. He was gone by Christmas with the sheriff's blessing and the whole of
it in the newspaper, and he never set foot in Caldera County again, and my
husband's father burned the letters he wrote asking to come home for
burying. What Mr. Bannister bought out of that estate was sold three times
before it was sold to him, gentlemen. I am sorry for his money. I have been
sorry for everybody's money that man ever touched. But sorrow is not title."
The silence that came down on the room then was of a kind Wade had heard
only once before in his life, at the creek on the third morning after the fire,
when the spring had run ash-dark for three days and then had begun to run
clear. It was the silence of a fact too plain to argue with arriving in public.
The court reporter, Wade noticed, did not look up. Her hands had never
stopped. She got it down whole β the stream sold twice more in 1913, the
sheriff, the burned letters β and Wade thought: there it is, it's in the book
now, and books outlive the men who lie in them and the men who are lied
about.
Beck asked no more questions. He said, "No further questions, Your Honor,"
with perfect courtesy, and sat, and opened the plaintiff's file in front of him
and began, while the court took up the next small matters, to read it from the
first page, the way a man reads a letter a second time after the news it carried
has changed.
They came back from the recess into a room that had changed its mind about
97
what kind of afternoon it was having, and the lawyer from Abilene rose with
a thin oilcloth notebook in his hand, the kind surveyors carry in a hip pocket
against the weather, and Wade felt his own heart go up into his throat like a
bird into a rafter, because they had had the notebook for six weeks β it had
come up out of the cousin's estate files in discovery, in a box of papers that