She had considered it in about the time it takes to pour a glass of water, and
had declined to recuse herself, and had said from the bench that if every
judge in West Texas who had ever drunk from a disputed spring stepped
down from a water case, the territory would have to try its water law by town
meeting, and she did not propose to start. Nobody had raised it since. Wade
believed her impartial the way he believed the spring cold: from experience,
87
and without being able to prove it to a stranger.
Harlan Beck rose for the plaintiff, and Wade made himself look at the man
fairly, because the case would be lost or won in part on whether he let
himself believe the other side was nothing but a bought suit of clothes. Beck
was not that. He was a tall, careful lawyer out of Fort Worth, with a voice
trained in rooms bigger than this one and the good sense to pitch it down for
a county courtroom, and he had the quality Wade respected in pipeline men
and horse traders: he believed his own paperwork. He laid the case out the
way a surveyor lays out a section, corner by corner, without hurry and
without heat.
The deed of 1911, he said. Executed by a Donnelly โ he used the name with
courtesy and let the room supply the rest โ conveying and severing, for
good consideration paid, the subterranean stream and waters beneath a
described tract of land in Caldera County. Purchased in the course of time,
through an estate, by his client, Clay Bannister, who stood now as holder of
that severed estate in the water, as a man might hold a mineral estate severed
from the surface, which Texas law had recognized since before anyone in
this room was born. The Donnellys, with all respect, occupied the surface.
Nobody disputed the surface. But the water beneath was a thing apart, and it
had been sold, and it had been bought, and the plaintiff asked the court to say
so, and to enjoin the waste โ he chose the word and set it down gently, like
a glass he did not intend to break โ the waste of the county's one reliable
water in an open pool, in an unfenced creek, in barrels given away to any
person who drove up with a thirst and a story, while the county died around it
at the rate of a farm a month.
He called a commissioner, and a man from the state engineer's office in
Austin who testified to the drought in the language of rainfall deficits, a gray
88
liturgy of inches that had not fallen, and a feed man from Loma Seca who
said, honestly enough, that he did not see how the town lasted another two
years on charity water and luck. And the burden of all of it, Wade saw, was
not greed, or not only greed. It was an argument, and it had a spine: that
water was too precious now to be governed by the customs of a wetter
century; that it had to be owned to be husbanded, piped, metered, sold, and
put to use, or the county would die sentimental, with its boots on and its
principles intact and its children gone to California. It was the drought's other
answer, and there were heads nodding along the right-hand benches, and
Wade could not honestly say the nodding was bought.
Then Beck called Clay Bannister, and the room did the thing rooms do when
the man himself takes the stand, which was to go a degree quieter than quiet.
Bannister was fifty-five, big through the shoulders gone a little to weight,
with a face that the sun had finished with years ago and left alone since. He
owned the land that flanked the Donnelly ranch on two sides and the bank
paper on half the farms on a third. He took the oath with his hand steady on
the Bible and answered Beck's questions in a voice that carried a natural
regret, like a man discussing a fence he is sorry to have to move. He had
bought the deed, he said, out of a cousin's estate sale in '49, among a box of
papers, oil leases mostly, most of them worth the match to burn them. He had
not known what he had until the drought deepened and his own wells began
to fail, and Beck had read the instrument and told him what it was. He had
offered to buy peace first โ he wanted that on the record โ and been
refused, not rudely, he granted that; refused the way you refuse weather. So
he had sued, because paper was what a man had when courtesy failed.
"Mr. Bannister," Beck said, "what do you propose to do with this water, if
the court confirms your title?"
89
"Cap the spring at the source," Bannister said, "and pipe it. Put in storage.
Serve my stock first โ I don't hide that, it's my water โ and sell the surplus
to the towns at a set rate, filed with the county, same for everybody. Build
something that lasts past the next rain, if rain's still a thing God's issuing." He
turned his head a fraction toward the room, and Wade saw that he meant
every word of it and that meaning it was the whole of the man's power. "I'm
not stealing water. I was born in this county same as the Donnellys. I've
watched it die for six years and I've listened to everybody in it talk about the