spring like it's a church. It isn't a church. It's water. It's the only water we've
got, and it's running out of an open hole in the ground into a creek that gives
half of it back to the sky by August. I am buying a future the Donnellys are
too sentimental to build. That's the whole of my crime, if it's a crime."
On cross, the lawyer Wade's money had hired β a quiet man out of Abilene
with a memory like a land office β asked him only a handful of questions.
Did Mr. Bannister dispute that Loma Seca households had drawn water at the
crossing freely, without payment or permission, for as long as any living
person could remember? He did not dispute it; it was the waste he was
describing. Had he, or anyone for the estate he bought from, ever in
forty-five years exercised any right under the deed β sunk a well on the
tract, drawn a gallon, posted a notice? Not that he knew of. The water had
been, as he put it, asleep in the paper. "And in 1911, Mr. Bannister β the
year of the deed β do you know the condition of the grantor?" Bannister's
mouth flattened. "I know what's said of him. A man isn't his cousin's keeper,
sir. I bought paper, not a pedigree." The lawyer thanked him and sat down.
The deed was still standing in the middle of the room like a fence across a
road. All the morning's testimony had walked around it. Nobody had yet
walked through it.
Mara Quinn took the stand after the noon recess, when the heat had settled
90
into the room like a tenant who intended to stay the season. She was
thirty-four, a geologist with the state water survey, with field boots under a
plain skirt and her hair pinned up by a woman who had dressed with her
mind already on the witness chair. The men along the walls had come
prepared to discount her β a state girl, a clipboard with legs β and she
undid them by being exactly as competent as the occasion required and not
one visible degree more. The lawyer from Abilene walked her through her
qualifications without flourish: survey parties in three drought counties; the
report on Caldera County waters the state had published the winter past,
which had called the Donnelly spring, in the flat prose of government, the
only reliable surface water in the county. She had written that sentence. She
stood on it.
"Miss Quinn," the lawyer said, "tell the court where the water in the
Donnelly spring comes from."
"It doesn't come from the creek," she said, "and it doesn't come from the rain
β not this year's rain, and not last year's. The spring rises on a fault." She
had brought a map, and the court let her stand by the easel, and with a
carpenter's pencil she drew the county's hidden architecture in front of
farmers who had walked that ground for sixty years and never once been told
it had a skeleton. "Here is your surface. Here, under the mesa, the limestone
beds are broken β tilted, dropped on one side of a fracture that runs roughly
northeast. Rain that fell before anyone's grandfather was born went down
through the fractured beds and collected in a deep aquifer, a body of water
under pressure, lying in broken rock below the reach of this drought and
below the reach of any drought in the record. The fault is a stairway. Where
the fracture reaches the surface β at the outcrop, on Donnelly land, at the
head of the creek β the pressure pushes the deep water up. That is the
91
spring. It is a well the earth drilled for itself, and it has been flowing for a
very long time before 1911 was a date."
"And its flow, Miss Quinn, in the present drought?"
"We gauged it first in the spring of '51, when the survey began, and we have
gauged it eleven times since, most recently in March of this year. Eleven
gallons a minute at the lowest reading, twelve and a fraction at the highest."
She said it without decoration. "Five years of the worst drought in the written
history of this part of Texas, and the variation in that spring is within the
error of my instruments. The surface wells in this county have fallen forty
feet and more. The spring has not fallen at all. That is what fault-fed means.
The drought doesn't know the address."
Then Beck rose to cross-examine, and Wade understood, watching the man's
unhurried courtesy, that Beck had been waiting for this witness all day β
because she was the defense's science, and science, in a courtroom, has to
survive being asked what it cannot do.
"Miss Quinn, your report is a fine piece of work. Let me ask you about its
limits. This aquifer of yours β can you tell the court its boundaries? Can
your science say where it ends, and under whose land it lies?"
"No," she said. "Not with certainty. It underlies a good deal of this county, on
the evidence of the well logs. I can map the fault. I cannot draw the water's
edges the way you'd draw a fence."
"And can your science tell the court who owns it?"
"No. The state cannot say who owns water underground. That is a question
of law, and I am not a lawyer. My science measures. It does not deed."
"Thank you. Then let me ask about a measurement. If the spring were