home black to the elbows, black to the knees, with his eyebrows singed. He
remembered that nobody in the house had said the word fire at the table for a
year afterward, as if the word itself were a coal that might still be live.
"Dad never asked me how it started," Jude said. He said it to the horses, to
the rail, to the dark beyond the yard โ anywhere but at Wade. "Not that
week. Not that winter. Three years, Wade. He ate at the same table with me
for three years, passed me the gravy, took my reports on the fences โ and he
never once asked me how that fire started."
The coffee steamed between them. Jude's hands were still on the rail, and
Wade could see, in the lantern light from the barn door, that they were
perfectly steady, which was how he knew what the steadiness was costing.
"I had it in speeches," Jude said. "Every night of that first year I lay in the
bunkroom making speeches. What I'd say when he asked. I had them
polished like stones. There's a kind of speech a man makes when the
answer's got weather in it โ bad luck, dry storm, nobody home โ and
there's the other kind. I made both kinds, some nights, to be ready either
67
way." He turned the cup a quarter turn on the rail, precise as a man setting a
survey marker. "He never asked. And I have never been able to decide, in
three years of deciding, whether that was mercy โ the biggest mercy I have
ever heard of a father paying out, to know a thing and carry it so his boy
didn't have to โ or the worst punishment ever devised by man, because a
punishment ends, Wade. A sentence has a number on it. You can count down
a sentence. But that โ " He lifted one hand off the rail and let it fall back.
"That just goes on being unasked forever. I don't know which one I'd rather it
had been. If it was punishment, it worked. If it was mercy, then I owe a dead
man a debt I can't pay and can't refuse, and there isn't a court in Texas with
the forms for it."
Wade said nothing. He understood, standing there with his own hands going
numb on the rail, that there were things a man could hand his brother and
things he could only stand next to while his brother held them, and that this
was the second kind, and that reaching for it would be a way of dropping it.
The mare shifted in the dark and sighed. Jude drank the last of his coffee and
set the cup down square on the rail.
"Leg's all right?" he said.
"Leg's all right. She's old and it's December."
"Aren't we all," Jude said, and went in, unhurried, across the yard with the
lantern light taking him and then the house door taking him, and no
confession followed him out into the cold because none had been made.
Wade stayed at the fence with the horses for a long while after, listening to
the windmill and the winter dark, and turning over what his brother had
actually given him, which was not a fact. It was a shape. He thought of the
lawyers in the county seat with their paper spring and their hearing in the
new year, where men in suits would argue about water none of them had ever
68
heard running under scorched rock โ and he understood that the lawsuit, for
all its filings and amendments, was the smaller of the two cases his family
was carrying. The other one had no courtroom and no opposing counsel and
no date set. It had a man who had been waiting three years for a question his
father carried into the grave instead of asking, and whatever lay under the ash
in Jude โ grief, guilt, some backfire of the heart set long ago to save the
place and gotten away from him โ that was the real lawsuit, the one that
would still be in session when the water case was a paragraph in a county
history. The horses breathed. The spring ran. Wade put his hands in his
pockets and stood a while longer in the cold, keeping the only watch he knew
how to keep: the watch of a man who has come home too late for the fire and
in time, perhaps, for whatever the fire left standing.
The wind came in on a Monday, out of the west, and by Tuesday it had
stopped being weather and become a condition of the house. It got in under
the doors and around the window sash no matter what Rosa stuffed in the
cracks. It sifted a fine gray flour of dust across the sills and the table and the
tops of the picture frames, and it worked its way into the flour bin and the
sugar and the seams of Wade's boots where he set them by the door at night.
The air went so dry that a man drew sparks off a door handle and off the
comb at the washstand, and his hair lifted and followed his hand like it
wanted to leave with it. Out in the pasture the grass stood cured to the color
of old rope, every stem of it, grama and tobosa and the little three-awn that
rattled when the wind combed it, and it made a sound going through it, a dry
whispering, like paper being handled in the next room.