Beck's own diligence had demanded and delivered to both sides alike β and
Wade had read it in his kitchen at two in the morning and understood that he
was holding the small, plain, field-penciled end of the whole war.
"Your Honor," the lawyer said, "the defense offers the original field notes of
the surveyor who ran the boundaries for the 1911 conveyance, obtained from
the grantor's estate files in discovery, and asks that the notes be marked and
read."
What the notes said was not complicated, which was the worst of it, because
complicated things can be argued and plain things can only be survived. The
surveyor, signing himself with initials and a date in October of 1910, had run
the tract the grantor intended to sell and described it in the field, in pencil, in
the order he walked it: beginning at the northwest corner of Section
Thirty-two, thence east along the section line, thence south β and so around,
four honest corners, closing true. The deed, drawn up later in an office in
Loma Seca by a clerk working from a letter, described the tract as beginning
at the northwest corner of Section Twenty-three. Twenty-three for
Thirty-two. The digits stood in each other's places like two mules hitched to
the wrong wagon, and between the deed's tract and the surveyor's there lay,
on the county plat the judge sent for and spread open on her own bench, the
whole width of the misunderstanding: Section Twenty-three was not the
mesa. It was not within two miles of the spring, nor of any land a Donnelly
had ever owned or claimed. Section Twenty-three, by the plat and the tax
98
rolls, was Clay Bannister's own north pasture β the land he had bought with
his father's money in 1928 and grazed his own cattle on for thirty years. The
subterranean stream the charming bankrupt had sold in 1911 rose, if it rose
anywhere under heaven, under grass that Clay Bannister already owned
outright, and the deed the plaintiff had carried into court like a drawn weapon
was a deed to water under his own fence.
The judge let the silence do the work a gavel would only have cheapened.
Beck stood at his own table with the oilcloth notebook open in both hands
and read it a second time, standing. Wade watched the exact moment pass
across his face, private and total β the moment a careful lawyer discovers
that his client's case has a hole in its first page β and felt no triumph, or a
triumph so quiet it felt like its opposite. The bricks of Beck's case were real.
The lot they'd been laid on was somebody else's. Beck closed the notebook
with care and said, "Your Honor, the plaintiff requests a recess until
tomorrow morning. There are matters I am obliged to take up with my client,
and one or two with myself." And Judge Foster, who had not smiled since
October, said, "Granted, Mr. Beck. The court thanks you for your candor," in
a tone that told the room she knew exactly how much the sentence had cost
him.
In the corridor, where the heat was joined by the smell of old varnish and
tracked-in dust, Beck came to Wade directly and stopped in front of him with
the notebook still in his hand, held out not as evidence but as a thing being
given back. "I want you to hear it from me before the morning," he said. "I've
filed paper in eleven counties, Mr. Donnelly. I've lost cases to better lawyers
and I've won them against worse facts, and I expect to do both again. But I
did not come to Caldera County to steal an old woman's water with a
misprint." He put the notebook into Wade's hands. "What my client does
99
tomorrow is his business and I'll advise him as his lawyer. What's in that
book was mine to find six months ago. Tell your mother" β and for the first
time in two days the trained voice gave way at the edges to something with a
hometown in it β "tell her the record got it right. Every word."
No verdict came down the next day, because by the next day there was, in
the judge's phrase, nothing left to try that a trial could improve. She took the
parties into chambers in the late morning β the Donnellys at one side of the
long desk, Bannister and Beck at the other, the court reporter left outside the
door β and Judge Foster, with her robe off, laid out the settlement she would
enter as the judgment of the court if the parties were wise, and would enter in
substance after verdict if they were not: one thing at a time, each in its place.
Title to the spring and its waters confirmed in the Donnellys, quieted against
the deed of 1911 and all claiming under it, forever. A public easement,
deeded and recorded, granting the households of Loma Seca and the
surrounding country the right of household water at the crossing β drinking,
cooking, the needs of a house β permanent, irrevocable, in drought or out of
it, so that what Rosa's father had ruled by custom in 1917 the law would rule
by record from 1956. To Bannister β and here she looked at him over her
glasses with the flat fairness that had made half the county fear her and the
other half swear by her β a livestock watering share at the creek below the
pool, a measured share, capped in gallons and in season, at a price the court