would set and review. His pipe-and-cap scheme at the spring itself: denied,
outright, in words she read from her own notes so there would be no
embroidery later — the spring was to remain uncapped, unfenced at the pool,
and flowing, the court having heard uncontradicted evidence that the
alternative was the death of the water for every interest in the room,
including the plaintiff's. And last, the smallest item, which Wade understood
100
last and valued first: the surveyor's field notes to be filed of record with the
deed, bound to it, indexed under both section numbers, so that the paper
could never be sold again — never lifted out of a box in some estate sale in
some future drought and carried into a courtroom against the water. The
misprint would ride with the deed forever, like a brand on a stray that has
been claimed and marked.
She let them sit with it. Rosa said, "The easement's for anybody that comes,
Judge. Not the town list. Anybody." "Any soul, Mrs. Donnelly," the judge
said. "I'll write it in words of one syllable so it survives us." Bannister sat a
long while with his big hands flat on his knees, a man doing arithmetic in a
currency he had not expected to be paid in, and at last he said, to the room
generally and to no one in it, "A capped share. At the creek. Below the pool."
"Below the pool, Mr. Bannister," the judge said. "Your cattle will drink what
the county's children have already had first use of. I find the order of it
recommends itself." He nodded once, the nod of a man closing a trade he
would not have chosen and could not call theft, and Beck, beside him, was
already turning to the clean sheets at the back of his file, beginning the
drafting in a small, exact hand.
Afterward, in the corridor, while Jude stood down at the far window with
their mother saying something that made the old woman laugh for the first
time in three days of court, Wade found himself standing next to Clay
Bannister at the tall window that looked west, the two of them with their hats
in their hands like men in a church neither had meant to enter. Beyond the
shimmering town, at the edge of sight, the mesa stood over the valley with
the grass-fire's work still on it from the spring — a long black shoulder of
burned ground running down to where the creek made its one green
argument through the ash. The spring up there had run dark for three days
101
after the fire and then clear, and it was running clear now, eleven gallons a
minute, in the sixth year of the drought, under a settlement not yet signed and
already more real than most things that had been.
Bannister looked at the burned mesa a long time. "They say that water's cold
enough to ache your teeth," he said at last. "Forty years I've heard it. Never
drank it. A man doesn't drink at another man's spring when he's figuring to
own it — that's a rule I made for myself, and kept, and it may be the sorriest
piece of bookkeeping I ever did." He turned from the window. "Is it as cold
as they say, Donnelly?"
Wade decided the man had had enough of other people's descriptions of
water he could walk to. "Come out Saturday," he said. "Bring a cup. Come
and drink and find out — same as everybody else." And Bannister looked at
him, and then out again at the green line holding its argument against the ash,
and nodded, slowly, like a man accepting terms he intended, for once, to
keep exactly as spoken.
A judgment, Wade learned, is a piece of paper until somebody drives stakes
into the ground, and the driving of stakes was how the spring of 1956 began
for the Donnelly ranch — not with lawyers, who had gone home to the
county seat with their briefcases and their fees, but with Mara Quinn on the
ridge above the creek crossing, one eye shut against the transit, calling
numbers down the line in the flat voice of a woman who intended the
numbers to outlive her.
The easement ran from the county road to the water, a strip forty feet wide,
surveyed, monumented, and recorded, and by Judge Foster's terms it
belonged to the families of Loma Seca forever, for household water, at the
102
crossing where the spring branch met the road. Wade worked the rear of the
chain and Jude the front, which meant Jude walked backward through the
brush holding the tape's end against each station while Mara read the angles,
and there was something in the arrangement that Wade kept noticing without
naming. The first time a surveyor had come onto Donnelly land uninvited,
the autumn past, it had been Bannister's man with a chain and a notebook up
on the Kitchen's rim, measuring for pipe, and Jude had gone for the rifle over
the kitchen door and their mother had stopped him with a single sentence.
Now the chain crew crossed the same pastures at walking pace and nobody
reached for anything. Jude held the tape. Mara called the numbers. The law,
it turned out, moved at the speed of a man walking backward through
mesquite, and perhaps that was why it lasted, when quicker things did not.
"Hold," Mara called.
Jude held. The wind worried the tape and she read it again and wrote the