the family: Beck had amended the Bannister claim a second time, and this
amendment cited the state survey by page and line โ Mara Quinn's own
measured figures, her own phrase perennial in character, entered now as
proof of the subterranean stream's substantial and severable value. Her data,
gathered in good faith at a listening rock in the dark, was out in the world
measuring the prize for the men who meant to take it. Wade remembered her
saying it would. He remembered that she had filed it anyway, because the
64
town was dying of thirst in a courtroom queue and the report was the price of
the trucks. It did not make the arithmetic kinder. It only made it arithmetic.
She came out to the ranch on the Sunday after, in the survey truck, and Wade
saw her from the corral and understood from the set of her shoulders through
the windshield that this was not an official visit. She got out at the gate โ
she did not drive in, she stopped at the gate, as a petitioner stops โ and Rosa
came down the yard to meet her with the unhurried walk of a woman who
has never once made another human being come the last ten feet of an
apology alone. Wade stayed at the corral fence with his coffee gone cold in
his hand and did not pretend he couldn't hear.
"I filed it true, Mrs. Donnelly," Mara said. She was stiff with it, and Wade
could hear that she had rehearsed the sentence on the drive out and that the
rehearsal was failing her now that it counted. "I want you to hear from me
what it has done. Beck is quoting my numbers in his amendment. I gave the
town its trucks and its well, and I gave him his evidence, and I knew when I
signed it that I was doing both. I am sorry for my half of that. It is the half I
could not see a way around."
Rosa looked at her a long moment. "Did I ask you to lie for us, Mrs. Quinn?"
"No, ma'am."
"Did your numbers lie?"
"No, ma'am. The spring is what I said it is."
"Then you have nothing of mine to apologize for." Rosa put her hand, briefly
and without ceremony, on the younger woman's sleeve, the way you'd steady
a horse that was thinking about shying. "Water that is reported is water
defended, Mrs. Quinn. What we have kept quiet in this family has not always
been kept safe. You wrote down what the canyon told you, and now the
65
whole state knows the canyon told the truth. Let Mr. Beck quote you. A true
thing quoted by a thief is still a true thing, and the court will have to step
over it to get to us. Come up to the house. There's coffee that isn't this one's
leavings." She nodded toward Wade, who lifted his cold cup in salute and
understood he had been made, graciously and by design, into the lesser
coffee's owner, and Mara Quinn laughed once โ startled out of herself, one
real laugh โ and walked up the yard with his mother in the winter light.
Wade watched them go and thought about how many kinds of honesty there
were, and what each of them cost. His mother paid in openness what his
brother paid in silence. He was still working out his own currency.
The cold set in earnest the week before Christmas and stayed, and on a night
three days short of the new year โ the hearing somewhere beyond it like a
fence line in the dark โ Wade came out after supper to check a mare that
had been favoring a foreleg and found Jude already there, standing at the
corral fence with his forearms on the top rail and a cup of coffee steaming
beside his elbow. Not a bottle. Coffee. Wade had been counting, the way you
count anything in a drought, carefully and without announcing the tally:
since the hospital, since Tommy Aguirre, his brother had not taken a drink
that Wade knew of, and the not-knowing was itself a kind of knowledge,
because Jude drunk was not a thing that hid. Jude sober and quiet at a fence
at night was a new animal, and Wade approached it the way you approach
anything new on a ranch โ not head-on.
He took the rail a few feet down and looked at the horses and let the silence
do its work. The mare's leg was sound enough; she was old, and the cold was
in her joints the way it was in his. The horses breathed in the dark, and
beyond the yard the windmill turned and complained and turned, and
somewhere out past the pasture the Kitchen country lay under the stars with
66
its water running cold in the black canyon, indifferent to hearings.
"You remember the summer of 'fifty-two," Jude said at last. It was not a
question.
Wade remembered it the way you remember a house you lived in burning: in
pieces, out of order, with the heat on his face. The drought then had been
young and mean, the grass gone by June. And then the fire โ the town's
story was lightning, a dry storm over the Kitchen country in the last week of
August, and the town's story had the virtue of being simple and the additional
virtue of being nobody's fault. He remembered his father on the porch
watching the smoke stand up over the canyon for two days, and Jude coming