92
developed β capped at the outcrop with proper engineering, piped, the flow
controlled by the lawful owner β your science cannot tell this court that the
water would be harmed, can it? The water would still be there. Underground.
Where it has been, as you say, since before there were deeds."
He had asked it kindly, almost gently, and it was the question the whole case
had been traveling toward, and Wade felt Jude go still beside him, watching
the wind.
"No," Mara Quinn said. "I can tell the court that, and I have the obligation to,
so I'll be careful. The water moves under pressure through fractured rock. It
is not a tank. It is not a lake sitting still in the dark waiting to be tapped
politely. The outcrop at the spring is the pressure's release β the one place
the fracture system breathes. If you cap that spring for a private pipe β cap
it, throttle it, draw it down at the rate an irrigation pipe draws β then on my
measurements the pressure in the fracture falls. The creek is fed by the same
pressure through the same broken beds, at a dozen seeps along its first two
miles. Drop the pressure and the seeps fail first, and then the outcrop begins
to suck air on the draw, and a fault spring that has taken air into its fractures
does not recover in a season. It does not recover in a decade. The spring as
the county knows it β eleven gallons a minute, drought or no drought β
would be dead inside a year. What you'd have left is a well, Mr. Beck. An
ordinary deep well, with an ordinary deep well's declining yield, under one
man's fence. You asked if the water would still be there. Some of it would,
for a while, the way a body of anything is still there while it's being spent.
The spring would not. I am not telling the court who owns the water. I am
telling the court what the water is, and I have measured it eleven times."
The judge had stopped making notes somewhere in the middle of it and was
watching the witness with her whole face. Beck stood a moment longer than
93
a man stands when his question has been answered to his satisfaction. He had
been given his concession β she had given it freely, twice β and it had
bought him nothing, because the thing she held, she held with both hands and
the numbers to prove it. "No further questions," he said, and sat down, and
Wade let out a breath he had been holding on his brother's behalf and his
mother's and the water's.
They called Rosa Donnelly in the middle of the afternoon, and the bailiff had
to ask the gallery twice to settle, which had not been necessary for any
witness before her, and Wade understood that the room was not being
disrespectful. Some of these people had been carried to that water as babies
in their mothers' arms, and all of them had drunk because of the rules she
was about to describe.
She took the oath in a voice that did not carry past the rail, and the judge
leaned forward a degree more and said, "Speak up for the reporter, Mrs.
Donnelly," and Rosa said, "Yes, ma'am," and did, by exactly the degree
requested and no more.
The lawyer from Abilene led her gently, and she laid out fifty years the way
she laid out a table, one thing at a time, each in its place. Her father β a
dry-land farmer with a divining rod he was half ashamed of and a memory
for green things β had found the spring in the summer of 1917, following a
line of mesquite that stayed leafed when everything else in the county had
gone to gray, and a flight of bees at evening going down into the rocks with a
purpose. He had dug with a pick in that heat for three days before the water
stood up in the hole black and cold and scared him half to death, she said,
and the room laughed the small laugh of people who have all been scared by
good news. Her father had set the rule the week he dug it, not her, she
wanted that understood. The water was God's and the earth's before it was
94
any Donnelly's. Household water was free to any soul who came for it, and
the pool was never to be fenced, because a fence at a spring in dry country
was a thing a man built to decide who lived, and her father had not been dug
out of the Panhandle in the nineties to come to Caldera County and decide
who lived.
"The thirties," the lawyer said. "Tell the court about the drought in the
thirties."
"We hauled in barrels then, same as now, except the wagons were horses."
She named the years the way other women name their children's ages.
"Thirty-four was the worst before this one. There was a queue at the crossing
from before light. Wagon, then two wagons, then the trucks when the trucks
came. My husband kept the book at the house β who came, how far, what
they carried away β not to charge them. So we'd know whose well had gone
and whose baby was new. The Ochoa family came eleven miles each way for
six summers. The Sartains lost their place in thirty-seven but they drank till
the day the bank took the roof. During the war it was the mothers mostly, and