twenty-nine years old and five years married to Henry Donnelly when my
father rode out to this ranch in that drought summer — rode out half-killed,
Jude, on a horse he had walked the last ten miles — and took my husband
aside after supper and told him where the water rose, and Henry understood
it for what it was, which is what it was: my dowry. Not land. The Donnellys
had land until a man got tired of looking at it. What Henry had married,
though he was too young and too proud to say so until he was fifty, was the
knowledge of where the water rises. The claim to this ranch is older than
Texas paperwork — the surface was granted in the Republic days, and
resurveyed, and patented, and there is a file in Austin with your
great-grandfather's name in Spanish on it, and not one line in that file about
water, because in eighteen forty a man did not write water down. Water was
not a thing you owned. It was a thing that was there, like the weather, and a
41
man who wrote it into a deed would have been laughed out of the land
office." Her voice did not rise. It never did, which was why men had always
listened to it. "Josiah Donnelly wrote it down in nineteen eleven because
Josiah Donnelly was a fraud and a drunk who would have sold the moon if a
buyer had brought a ladder. He sold Mr. Bannister's grandfather's lawyers a
stream he had never seen, under land he had never stood on, and the selling
of it is all the deed is. But a deed is a hard thing to argue with in a courtroom,
and that is why we will argue with more than the deed."
"What more is there, Mother?" Jude said, and it was not insolence; it was a
man asking for his orders.
"There is the use of it," Rosa said. "Thirty-eight years this family has watered
this town out of that basin and never charged a cent and never kept a name
on a list. There is not a court in Texas that does not know what thirty-eight
years of open use means. And there is the rock." She pointed the stick down
at the shoulder of stone. "Mr. Beck's engineers will come with their chains
and their levels, and they will measure everything about that spring except
the one thing that matters, which is that it rises where it rises by God's
geology and not by any man's deed, and if they cap it—" For the first time
her composure showed its seam; she stopped, and breathed, and finished
more quietly. "If they cap it wrong, they will kill it. Springs like this one are
not wells. You do not drill them and you do not cap them. You ask them. My
father asked it. I have asked it every year of my life. That is the whole of my
testimony, and I will say it in Judge Foster's courtroom in my good dress,
and if that is not the law, then the law will have to look at me while it says
so."
On the walk back up out of the Kitchen the sun was full on the mesa and the
day had started its long cruelty, and Wade found himself counting the green
42
of the cottonwoods against the black of the burned canyon, and thinking
about oil money in a bank in Odessa, and not liking the shape of the thought,
and not being able to put it down either.
The town began to divide itself within the week, the way a river divides
around a stone — without drama, and without ever quite saying so, and
Wade marked it in the small coin of errands. Loma Seca had run on Donnelly
water for so long that taking it had become invisible, a thing the town did the
way it breathed: the barrel wagon on Tuesdays and Fridays behind Jude's old
team, the cans lined up at the standpipe Rosa's rules governed — households
first, gardens second, no man's stock watered out of turn, no charge ever
asked or taken. Now there was a paper in the courthouse that said the
breathing had been theft all along, and the town did not know where to put its
hands.
The church supper on the last Wednesday of October was where Wade saw
the shape of it whole. The Baptist fellowship hall, potluck against the
drought — beans and cornbread and a ham somebody's brother had sent from
Oklahoma — and the seating arranged itself the way seating in a small town
arranges itself, which is to say exactly like a map of the truth. At the long
table by the kitchen sat the haulers: the Aguilars, whose seven children drank
Donnelly water; old Mr. Pruitt, who had sold Bannister nothing and said so
at volume; the widow Ferro, whose garden was the only green thing on Elm
Street and who had already told two people that if the water stopped she
would take her husband's pistol and shoot the spring's cap off herself,
whatever a cap was. At the table by the windows, nearer the door and the
evening, sat the others: two families whose sons loaded trucks at the feedlot;
the Santa Rosas, who had sold their north section in August and were eating
better than anyone in the hall and enjoying it least; and Lyle Ferris from the
43
hardware store, who kept his eyes on his plate and his family close around
him like a wall.