a country gone the color of ash. Wade understood that whatever ran in that
canyon ran in his mother too, and that she had kept the spring for fifty years
not as a possession but as a trust, handed down from the man who'd first
heard it under the rock.
She met Henry Donnelly in 1911, the year of the deed. She remarked on that
herself, as they worked, without flinching from it, the way a woman notes a
dark coincidence in a family Bible. A drilling company had come into the
valley that spring putting down wells for the moneyed places, and Henry was
on the crew, twenty-three years old, a Texan with forearms like rope and a
silence on him that the other young men mistook for slowness because they
had not yet learned what it was. The Herreras' well was the last on the
contract. It came in sweet at ninety feet, and Rosa, sixteen and already
incapable of being impressed on schedule, carried the crew's dinner out to the
rig with her sisters and found the big quiet Texan staying an hour past the
whistle to show her father how the pump head would want greasing, his
hands gentle on the iron as if it were a horse's mouth.
"He courted me with a wrench in his hand," she said. "Which is the only
honest way, though I did not know it then. He stayed three extra days in that
valley, Wade, and in three days he repaired our headgate, reset two fence
corners, and said perhaps forty words. My father told my mother: that one
will either be a husband or a fence post, and either way the farm can use
him." She almost smiled, sixty years later, in the cold tack room, with the oil
shining on her hands. "He was a fence post about some things. I will not
pretend otherwise to you. But a fence post does not rust, and it does not run,
and in 1911 those were not small recommendations."
57
The deed itself she saved for the kitchen, and for night, and for a moment
when Jude was out at the pens and the house was only theirs. Wade had
asked โ finally, plainly, the way he'd been rehearsing since August โ who
it was that had signed the paper Clay Bannister was waving at them out of a
bank vault.
"Your great-uncle," Rosa said. "Your grandfather's youngest brother. Josiah
Donnelly." She said the name the way you'd set down a glass you didn't trust
the table with. "Oh, he was the charm of three counties. Racehorses in
Monterrey. A silver mine that was a hole with a story on it. A saloon in El
Paso that burned, conveniently, twice. Your grandfather fed that man for ten
years, Wade โ ten years of his beef at this table โ and paid his debts clean
through twice, because he was blood and because his own father on his
deathbed had extracted a promise. And in all that decade, with all that charity
running, this family never once let Josiah Donnelly hold a horse's halter."
She looked up from the papers she was not reading. "Do you understand me?
A man who will sign anything will sell anything, given a pen and a witness.
A horse at least has the sense to pull back. They knew what he was. They fed
him anyway. That is a thing a family can do โ feed a man and not trust him
โ and it is not a contradiction. It is the whole of wisdom about some
people."
In the autumn of 1911, broke again and charming as a saint's day, Josiah had
signed it: a deed severing the waters beneath the surface of the ranch's
western range โ the broken rock country, the Kitchen country, land he'd
never ridden, water he'd never seen nor heard โ sold for four hundred
dollars and a team of mules to men who wanted a map with a river drawn on
land that hadn't got one. The paper had gone into a drawer, then a vault, then
into the keeping of Cousin Augustus in Fort Worth, and slept through two
58
generations while the spring it described ran cold under the scorched rock for
anyone Rosa's father, and then Rosa, gave leave to. Clay Bannister had
bought it out of Augustus's estate for cash โ a drought being the exact
season when a dead man's signature on underground water becomes worth a
lawyer.
"The deed is real paper, Wade," Rosa said. She folded her hands on the table,
and her voice went down to the register she used for weather and for deaths.
"His signature is on it, in his hand, which I would know among a thousand.
And it is a lie at the same time. He sold what was never his alone to sell,
water he had never seen, under land he had never set foot on, to men who
wanted a map with a river drawn on land that hadn't got one. Real paper, and
a lie. That is the worst kind there is, because the court can only see the
paper." She was quiet a moment. "Your grandfather paid Josiah's last debts
and buried him in 'thirty-one, and Henry never spoke his name at this table
again. I am speaking it now because Harlan Beck is speaking it in a
courtroom. That is the only reason."
Tommy Aguirre was twelve years old, all elbows and questions, the middle
boy of the family that hauled water at the crossing every Thursday with two